Thursday, March 18, 2010

Buffett, Jacobi and Einstein

“What are your thoughts about the presidential election”? The writer has been asked a few times. He’s delighted that our media is preoccupied with quizzing the candidates and reporting extensively about who and what the candidates are. Given their efforts to assess the candidates on vital issues, the writer offers the following quotes – he’s spoken about . . . focus, “starting with the end in view”, culture and barriers, among others . . . and it seems worthwhile to hear respected individuals, from contemporary and historical times.

Warren Buffett: “It’s important to Charlie Munger, my long-time partner, and me that all of our owners understand Berkshire’s operations, goals, limitations and culture. In each annual report, consequently, we restate the economic principles that guide us . . . Berkshire has adhered to these principles for decades and will continue to do so long after I’m gone . . .

“Long ago, Charlie laid out his strongest ambition: ‘All I want to know is where I’m going to die, so I’ll never go there.’ That bit of wisdom was inspired by Jacobi who counseled “Invert, always invert” as an aid to solving difficult problems . . . Charlie and I avoid businesses whose futures we can’t evaluate, no matter how exciting their products may be . . .” (Should remind us of garment exports and semi-conductors; and now BPOs. Are we pursuing higher-value added BPOs to raise and sustain competitiveness? It’s numbing sitting on one’s laurels?)

Jacobi (the great Prussian mathematician): “Invert, always invert” – “that the solution of many hard problems can be clarified by re-expressing them in inverse form”. Albert Einstein: “The value of education is not the learning of many facts but the training of the mind to think.”

This brings the writer to one question to a candidate and his response: How to improve national competitiveness? “Do away with degree consciousness for promotions. One need not have a master’s degree for leadership skills and institutional knowledge”.

And here’s the writer’s definition of leadership, the outcome of decades of practice and more recently consulting: “The belief and ability to predict failure or success” – so that the leader doesn’t drive us over the cliff, and instead navigate the way to the ‘promised land’!

But in a democracy we get the leaders that we deserve; and we are defined by our values and our culture. For example, if we don’t value excellence and thus set a low bar, our leaders will gravitate to populist demands even if they’re counterproductive? And this reality is entrenched by a culture of inclusion – as opposed to one that values focus and priority?

The bottom line: one person can’t solve our problems. We as a people must elect the right leader – but it is incumbent upon us to give him the confidence that he can lead us on a new path, the way forward. To insist that he views the world with us – through the one prism of “Pinoy kasi” – will sink us into the abyss! We’ve had a succession of failed leaderships and failed economies – because our aversion to change made us reject progressive options?

We’ve shaped for our leaders the condition that’d make it convenient and rewarding for them to fail. For instance, we expect them to patronize us (“mababaw ang kaligayahan”) so patronage is well ingrained. We value hierarchy and elevate them above and beyond the rules of integrity – especially if we share the spoils of the system. For example, “tax amnesty” has become a way of life! We’ve created a vicious circle that’d yield a failed leadership and a failed economy every election cycle – thus our decades-old decay?

Saturday, March 13, 2010

How we can get things done?

The Export Development Council’s (EDC) website pages the writer had browsed recently seem to have disappeared? Or is the website under construction or re-construction or re-design? In any case, it gave the writer the opportunity to browse the website of the NCC or National Competiveness Council.

The NCC website reads: “The NCC was formed in October 2006 as a Public-Private Task Force on Philippine Competitiveness by virtue of Presidential Executive Order (EO) No. 571 to address the improvement of the country’s competitiveness from the bottom third of competitiveness rankings to the top three by 2010.” (It is early in 2010, but do we expect to lift our competiveness ranking to the top three by year’s end?) Two of the NCC’s focus areas call for: providing seamless infrastructure network and developing energy cost competitiveness and self-sufficiency.

If it is not obvious yet, the writer offers specifics – and is committed to engaging opinion makers and leaders. For example, he has talked about Maslow’s hierarchy of human needs – and it appears that we Filipinos are still struggling to attain the most basic of needs: water, food, power, etc., etc. Net, the goal of the NCC is simply too lofty – given that while we have incurred record levels of debt over several decades and several administrations, we’re still at ground zero. It simply is not doable! If we are to keep a mature optimism we must first be dogged and get the foundation (infrastructure) of these basic human (Filipino) needs right!

Many times initiatives fail because people approach challenges in a linear fashion – not surprising because logic dictates that we move from step one then step two, etc. The writer has talked about “starting with the end in view.” This is not an alien concept because we grew up being asked: what do you want to be when you grow up? (For instance, in tourism, to develop a competitive instinct, our thought process could be: Which are our benchmark countries in developing our initiative? How many tourists do they attract? How many can we attract and should attract? How much revenue must we generate? Are we focused on the 12 top tourist attractions – focus, being the operative word? How does the infrastructure network of these attractions match up against those of other countries? How does our cost structure match up? How do our marketing efforts match up?)

The end point of competitiveness is a product or service that is preferred by the customer or the consumer. Yet it has to be in context. Competiveness in an economy must come from the elements of our economic output or GDP: domestic and foreign output. Our domestic output already outstrips our neighbors’! Where we have a gaping hole is in our foreign output! And this is where we’ve fallen flat on our face – because we don’t have the confidence and skills-set to compete, i.e., compelling products with healthy margins, in the international arena; or we simply are inward-looking and parochial, it is not even on our radar screen?

Net, our initiatives, defined by their end goal, will have two elements that: (a) spell out the objectives we must pursue to drive our foreign output, e.g., our strategic initiatives; and (b) spell out the requisite infrastructure that will directly enable these strategic initiatives, including basic infrastructure, i.e., water, food, power, etc. It will take us years to move up the competiveness ranking, but we can start with a sharper perspective of our end goal! (But we’ll never make it if integrity and excellence in our initiatives are absent – while influence peddling and small thinking and incompetence dominate? For example, the BCDA’s handling of the SCTEX contract is sheer incompetence! This is a major project yet we failed to prequalify the right bidders thus are left with two unacceptable bids? We can’t attract world-class contractors – they will not bet on us, as shown by a European bank that unloaded their Philippine bonds, being the worst performer this year; and thus raising our cost of borrowing?)

Wednesday, March 10, 2010

“Fully engaging the global economy”

It appears that Filipinos are visiting Vietnam and Cambodia, and find them interesting and promising. The writer had done business in Vietnam when it opened its doors and was keen to make a nostalgic trip.

These countries, probably desperate to jumpstart development, have indeed opened their doors. The writer remembers flying Vietnam’s local airline almost 20 years ago and hearing the voice of the French pilot. This time, he hears an Australia pilot and also a Korean pilot. In Siem Reap the writer checks out the label of a popular beer – and it comes from Singapore. The tour guide explains that he can buy a local SIM card and has a choice of carrier – that aside from local carriers, there are foreign ones too: Vietnamese, Malaysian, Thai, etc.

It seems Filipinos like the rest of the world expect Vietnam to develop faster than the Philippines especially given that they have more than twice our gross investment – and more than twice the value of foreign equity investment. And since Cambodia is drawing tourists in abundance, will we see Cambodia developing at a faster clip too?

We don’t need foreign pilots because we’ve been training and developing pilots for generations. But if that is our reaction, we’re missing the phenomenon going on in Indochina. For instance, where is San Miguel and PLDT when our neighbors have all planted stakes in this fast-developing part of the region? (In fairness the writer saw a San Miguel neon sign in Ho Chi Minh. And with Kirin’s equity in San Miguel, it appears the international unit is geared to be more focused. But currently, in Vietnam, their product-distribution coverage and marketing efforts aren’t competitive!) That’s the stark face of competition – and it’s real! Do we then intellectualize our response and conclude that what we need is more OFWs? Is national pride inhibiting us from heeding the World Bank and ADB, i.e., that “we must be fully engaging with the global economy”? Or does our way of life have very little propensity for change?

San Miguel and PLDT are two of our premier enterprises – and should be aggressively expanding their markets beyond the Philippines? PLDT is NYSE-listed; it is not surprising if foreign investors value their competitiveness in the Philippines; and the continued OFW remittances. But stock market investors are short-term driven, i.e., we can’t take it as an endorsement of our economic fundamentals. The test of (foreign) investor confidence is in the size of their equity investment and we pale in comparison to Vietnam – another stark reality!

Is it surprising then that we are the region’s economic laggards? Indochina is less developed than the Philippines. Their infrastructure is underdeveloped. Doing business in these countries requires lower overhead versus doing business in the developed world, for example. Indochina is still low-cost and thus affordable to hire resources: (a) to do market research and understand the consumer, (b) figure out the trade structure and thus pinpoint where to focus distribution efforts, i.e., via the 80-20 rule, (c) put up a manufacturing facility, and (d) to do marketing. Indochina is not a small market – the population is 108 million, a bit more than the Philippines. And the latest poverty reports in Vietnam and Laos are better than ours. (The object of the writer’s efforts in Vietnam years ago has gone full circle – i.e., he had a big smile watching the product’s TV commercial in his hotel room!)

Of course we must play an honest-to-goodness competitive game, i.e., as foreigners we can’t play the power or influence-peddling game that our major enterprises are adept in playing in the Philippines. In Indochina the local companies can play the game, but foreign companies can’t. It takes one to be truly competitive to succeed beyond its borders – and that means developing compelling products with healthy margins. Net, our industry needs to upgrade its skill-set in product development in order to be competitive!

Should we start learning the ropes and stake our claims in less formidable markets like Vietnam and Cambodia? And aspire to be a global, competitive player? It’s never easy to do business beyond one’s borders. But Pacquiao would not be world-class if he stayed home!

Sunday, March 7, 2010

Competitiveness: Where are we?

Beyond the Terminal 3 (NA) international airport fiasco, local papers are a buzzed re two controversies: (1) defining and taxing oil imports, and (2) the case between a generic and a branded drug. We are pitted against the Germans, the British and the Dutch, and the Americans. Or are we pitted against ourselves – and we are our worst enemy? Is the suspicion of corruption at the heart of the Terminal 3 imbroglio and the taxing of oil imports? And in all 3 cases, are we invoking victimhood – that we are being victimized by the big guys?

We were fascinated by Barack Obama and dissected his candidacy – yet did we miss its true import? Barack Obama turned victimhood on its head! If there’s a lesson we want to discern from Obama, it is that victimhood equates to defeatism! If we think like winners we can turn victimhood/defeatism on its head? But can we win despite the Germans, the British and the Dutch, and the Americans? How did our neighbors do it? As the World Banks reminds us, they did it by: (a) fully engaging with the global economy, (b) maintaining macroeconomic stability, (c) mustering high rates of savings and investment, (d) letting markets allocate resources and (e) electing committed, credible and capable governments.

China is now in a contest with Japan to be the second largest economy. Yet not too long ago China was isolated from the rest of the world – its economy suffered . . . and thus had to address the discontent of its people. China then opted to be a market economy and tapped the requisite elements of competitiveness: foreign capital, foreign market, foreign technology and foreign expertise!

Do we want to connect the dots in order to attain competiveness – or fortify influence peddling instead a la Dick Cheney? Two news reports can’t be ignored: (a) NEDA sees Ps 554 B annual infra spending, and (b) Tollway proponent short of funds – wants subsidy. In one article government proudly says: “It is a solicited private-sector project without any form of government guarantee, a pure private-business venture.” Yet the other reads: “government can offer bridge funding . . . adding that the money could be sourced from the proceeds of the P50-billion infrastructure bonds that NDC would float . . . Earlier, DMCI said that PIDC would raise P10 billion in debt . . . the balance . . . would come in the form of equity. DMCI had subscribed to more than 1.4-million common shares of PIDC . . . DMCI had said that the San Miguel group would raise its stake in PIDC to 49 percent, and later on to 51 percent.”

Are we being transparent in pursuing major initiatives? Infrastructure raises efficiency and thus critical to the competitiveness of our strategic industries. In the case of tourism, for example, it appears we have 12 destinations generating the largest revenues. What piece of the infrastructure spending is allocated to raise the competitiveness of these revenue generators – that visitors coming over for a holiday will have a pleasant experience, i.e., our infrastructure from point a to point b is efficient, not gold-plated? How much income do we expect from tourism if it is a strategic industry? We can’t define our strategic initiatives in wishy-washy fashion – i.e., it equates to influence peddling, abuse and corruption, or why investors skip us!

How badly do we want to develop the competitiveness of our industry? How can San Miguel be a preferred provider – and allotted subsidy – on a business it is not industry leader and innovator, for example? Is San Miguel doing a Warren Buffett, building up its portfolio? Buffett invests to make money – not to seek government subsidy. He stepped in to bailout an investment bank before and recently made a huge bet on the railroad industry, an asset not only to himself but the nation! Buffett is not Cheney! But are we in fact disciples of Cheney’s bunker-mentality and influence peddling, i.e., inward-looking and hierarchical?

Wednesday, March 3, 2010

Thinking small

We need every ounce of competitive edge yet – given “que sera sera” or “bahala na”? – we don’t bat an eyelash watching a white elephant in our midst? What coach will bench an NBA superstar like LeBron? That’s what we did with Terminal 3 of NAIA? Do we find virtue in self-flagellation?

It is refreshing that a presidential candidate is talking about ambition – encouraging Juan de la Cruz to be ambitious. We better dig it from our arsenal – lest we find ourselves in a race to the bottom? Man – from Eden . . . all the way through . . . the moon, where he made the giant step for mankind – was meant to think big! But what about the vulnerable – they can’t think big?

And so the poor seek refuge in Church – and her efforts to help the poor have to be anchored on sustainability. Given a third of Filipinos are poor, we have a heavy load to carry – and to address squarely, knowing full well manna from heaven doesn’t pour on them 24/7.

Talking to a provincial superior and his team and some nuns, it appears that feeding the poor has become the vocation of the Church in the Philippines. And to ensure sustainability, they are focusing on what they call IGPs or income-generating projects. The writer is impressed: here are two church groups pursuing a merger no different from the way private business does it. The priests demonstrate savvy in strategic thinking and finance – they’re exploring taking over the undertaking of a nun who’s well past retirement. To the provincial superior it’s no brainer: our mission is to heal and work with the sick, and handicapped people are near and dear to our hearts. Yet, they’re assessing which of the projects is sustainable – and ought to be the core undertaking. Clearly, these priests understand discipline and focus!

Our industry is likewise sensitive to the less fortunate and is committed to CSR or Corporate Social Responsibility. Yet, after spending a few days in Davao, the writer can’t help wonder: are we thinking big to help ourselves and solve our problems? The writer and family have been to other major cities and towns – e.g., in Cebu, Bohol and Iloilo – the past couple of years; and were wondering as much.

The Eden nature park at the foot of Mount Apo and the “Pearl Farm” Beach Resort on Samal Island should make the locals proud. But the Davao Insular hotel is no longer conspicuous – how dense the city has grown, no longer rural and green with countless coconut trees! Density is associated with India or China yet every major metro area in the Philippines is bursting at the seams.

It is liberating that while conventional wisdom reinforces our conservative beliefs, priests and nuns can be far more engaging – willing to discuss moral ethics, for example. Have we narrowed our perspective in religion, education, and economic development thus feeding our inward-looking bias? Western Catholic theologians were critical of the last encyclical – for trying to address every contemporary issue and thus missed delivering a profound message. The Church is a community – and the faithful’s role is to engage, not to be subservient! Isn’t that what we told the Spanish Friars? Or have we forgotten?

The bottom line: efforts by the Church and industry to help the poor are encouraging – but they fall short. The billions of dollars of OFW remittances fall short likewise. Net, we can either: (a) think big, “fully engage with the global economy”, like our neighbors do as the World Bank reminds us or (b) simply accept that we’re vulnerable . . . and thus helpless, in a race to the bottom?

Friday, February 26, 2010

The genius of the Great Commandments

It is amazing how much we have dissected our challenges: economic, political and poverty, among others – yet we haven’t moved forward! Problem-solving, unfortunately, is not dissertation-writing.

Leaders who move their country forward are clear-thinking decision-makers – not trapped by analysis-paralysis! Beyond staying on message, they stay with time-tested principles – they have internalized the genius of the Great Commandments! FDR was elected three times – he stayed with his New Deal message and as importantly, focused on the vital few initiatives that defined his agenda. Clinton overshadowed the perspective of Bush 41 during the campaign and carried his mantra – “it’s the economy, stupid! – through two terms that saw one of the longest economic expansions in America. Perfection is not what moves a country forward!

But do we stop short when confronted with a challenge – and dance around it instead? And euphemistically call it “Filipino abilidad”? Unable to pursue industrialization, we pride ourselves instead for fielding millions of OFWs globally? Haven’t we learned that bolos couldn’t win against the cal. 45? And given industry is high up in our hierarchy, we keep pressing poor Juan de la Cruz to take the slack of a failed economy? Do we want to upgrade nursing education to generate more OFWs? Is that “Filipino abilidad” or abdication – “to whom much is given, much is expected”? (What about countryside development? It has a caveat, i.e., sustainability. The commune system did not break poverty in China. Industrialization drastically reduced it – they tapped the requisite elements of competitiveness: capital (foreign), market (global/economies of scale), technology (foreign) and expertise (foreign). They leveraged globalization to attain competiveness – the Holy Grail!)

Our industry is inward-looking; but meets the needs of the few (e.g., monopolies and conglomerates) and thus the rewards to them are a windfall. And given our hierarchical culture, we make them larger than life – that they can’t do wrong? What is reality – we’re not an industrial, first-world country because we don’t have a big industrial base as Gokongwei pointed out, for example?

What we have is a glaring crisis to confront: every contemporary global yardstick that measures a nation’s progress – especially development, competitiveness, corruption and economic freedom – has failed to galvanize us! A columnist discusses the efforts of the UP community to spell out the challenges for the next president. And he laments that the outcome largely calls for political will – and thus falls short? Or was it an exercise in dissertation-writing, an attempt to cross all the t’s and dot all the i’s and thus missed the knock-out punch? Perfection is not what moves a country forward!

What is there to dissect but for the national leadership to work with the private sector to pursue industrialization? 98 million Filipinos with a GDP per person of $3,300 (PPP) can’t drive the economy like the US does – with a-$46,400 GDP per person – that is, skewed to consumption! The reality is: the US is a multi-trillion dollar economy with a humongous export industry albeit the US consumer had demanded more cheap foreign goods. The US is more than a consumption-driven economy – it’s a fully industrialized, export powerhouse (e.g., GE, Boeing, Microsoft, etc.) on top of their capacity for capital formation and product-idea generation. Of course, they have their Achilles heel – their bigger than Texas-sized deficit and a dysfunctional Washington – but that’s another topic altogether. We better focus on our crisis – our own crisis!

Our penchant for “kuro-kuro” (or circular arguments that don’t get closure thus equate to muddled thinking?) and “kwentong kutsero” (or assertions that are suspect?) create failed efforts like the Terminal 3 of the (NA) international airport? It is a critical infrastructure element for stepped-up economic activity with the outside world – if we missed its import? Of course there are legal issues! Getting ourselves in a no-win situation is something we need like a hole in the head?

Tuesday, February 23, 2010

Pursuing strategic industries

New export road map to be drafted”, says a news article. And it drew the writer’s attention, and led him to the EDC’s (Export Development Council) website. So far we have 3 groups in government pursuing strategic industries to boost the country’s competitiveness?

The EDC had earlier spelled out (for 2005-2007) what they called interventions to support specific industry clusters. And the writer perused two in particular: electronics and food. Clearly the West can share a thing or two about competitiveness: for instance, their R&D mantra is “start with the end in view”. It simply means that instead of figuring out the first step of an initiative, we must first ascertain what the end looks like. And the preceding steps (i.e., the vital few!) must be geared to the attainment of that end goal. How does that work in developing our electronics and food initiatives?

If we go to a supermarket we won’t miss the strong presence of Nestlé products, for example. And if we visit their website we will even get a sense of their business: “Nestlé is the world's leading Nutrition, Health and Wellness company. We are committed to increasing the nutritional value of our products while improving the taste. We achieve this through our brands and with initiatives like the Nutritional Compass and 60/40+.”

The key is to understand how global companies view the industry and their businesses. For instance, in our own food initiative we can adopt an approach similar to Nestlé’s in creating high value-added products: (a) deliver the specific benefits (for example) of nutrition, health and wellness, and (b) win the consumer’s trust via well-developed branded products. To that end, our industry needs a major break from tradition: raise their investment especially in R&D and product development, quality assurance and marketing, including consumer insights. Nestlé spends over 2% of revenues (twice the industry norm) in R&D; while we as a nation spend less than the industry. Clearly we’re not geared to be competitive. The writer opened an impressive, export-quality looking Philippine branded nuts, vacuumed sealed and all, but the quality of the nuts inside was not worth the expensive packaging; and foreigners have complained about this before – and in some cases the can is rusted by the time it gets to a store shelf overseas! This is a waste of investment meant to establish trusted branded products, which we can’t afford!

To truly understand the industry, we can invite representatives from major global companies to share their insights. And if we do, the interaction can open our eyes (and theirs!) to partnership opportunities: from agriculture to manufacturing to marketing to sales and distribution, locally and beyond.

We can go through a similar exercise with electronics or ICT (Information & Communication Technology) or BPO: in order to develop a truly globally competitive industry initiative we ought to pick the brains of major industry players who set the tone for and define the industry. For instance, have we considered inviting Bill Gates or some respected personality in ICT to edify us on the product architecture of the BPO industry? High value-added products and services come to light when we “start with the end in view” – it pulls us from being stuck to the past!

We can move up the value chain of our strategic industries, beyond dried mangoes and semi-conductors, for example – but we don’t have to do it by ourselves: we should make globalization work for us!

The bottom line, always: the revenues we need to generate across these strategic industries must cover our GDP shortfall – to the extent of 80% over a 5-year period of our incremental GDP target of $100B, for example.