Sunday, April 11, 2010

Capitalism and democracy: no cake walks

Whenever the writer is flying to Eastern Europe, given the language barrier, he would ask for English periodicals – and the flight attendant would typically hand him a pile. Two articles recently attracted his attention: (a) What went right (in Eastern Europe’s economies) and (b) How democracy dies.

The Economist says: “If Spain, Portugal, Italy and Greece want a lesson in how to take hard decisions, they should look eastward . . . The cuts in spending and increases in taxes and the retirement age that some ex-communist countries have imposed over the past year were much more savage than anything that Greece or Spain have so far contemplated . . .”

And Newsweek asserts: “A global decline in political freedom is partly the fault of the middle class . . . Many of the same middle-class men and women who once helped push dictators out of power are now seeing just how difficult it can be to establish democracy, and are pining for the days of autocracy . . . the public in many countries, who became disgusted that these democrats seemed no more committed to the common good than their authoritarian predecessors . . .”

We’re not alone in our reluctance to take hard decisions; and we’re not alone either in being disgusted with the country’s leadership.

Given the last several years – working and traveling around Europe – the writer appreciates the perspective of The Economist: countries may not be predisposed to take hard decisions. It’s worth noting that the countries referenced are favorite tourist destinations, i.e., Spain, Portugal, Italy and Greece. Being welcoming and cordial doesn’t come together with the instinct to take hard decisions?

Ex-communist countries, on the other hand, could “impose much more savage spending cuts and increases in taxes.” While the old system provided them with basic necessities it also conditioned them to accept a lot of restrictions – e.g., limited choices of if not outright ban on a number of things. In short, spending cuts and tax increases could be more palatable to them. And given the global recession, such “flexibility” was precisely what “the doctors ordered”? To be sure, The Economist recognizes that “ex-communist Europe still has to grapple with its share of problems: an ageing workforce, bossy officials and poor infrastructure . . . To catch up on the what the region missed when it was behind the Iron Curtain remains a mighty task.”

In any case, Newsweek makes an interesting point: capitalism and democracy have taken a beating because of: (a) the war on terror post 9/11 starting with the US invasion of Iraq; and the subsequent difficulty of establishing democracy in the country, (b) the global recession following the collapse of the global financial system owing to greed and irresponsibility in the West and (c) failure of democratically elected leaders in many countries, e.g., Thaksin in Thailand, and Estrada in the Philippines.

Capitalism and democracy are no cake walks – but people and countries could make the choice and be committed to the common good. Indeed, the way to righteousness – the common good – is straight and narrow? As even Gorbachev recognizes in his self-criticism of Russia?

Thursday, April 8, 2010

Rebooting our economy

Inertia is a given and hence we can’t expect ourselves to turn on a dime and stare at a clean slate. But a clean slate is what we need in order to chart a new, progressive course. Job one: figure out how to raise our GDP per person – it’s our true north but let’s not get ahead of ourselves! A clean slate means we’re not hostage to old assumptions – because we now know where we stand, as an economy and as a global competitor.

Do we want an economy that is inward-looking, and thus lag the region in investment? Do we want OFW remittances to drive our economy, and thus miss the imperative of developing and marketing competitive products – e.g., we need an incremental $100 billion, against the global economy it’s miniscule; the issue against exports does not apply to a small fry like us although even Obama wants to double US exports to $2 trillion? Do we want to be everything to everybody and thus miss to prioritize – confine our infrastructure and strategic industries to underdevelopment? Do we want to be simply fighting fire, and thus render us inefficient, ineffective and open to corruption – e.g., importing grains, installing generators, etc.? Do we want to keep taking the path of least resistance, and thus inhibit us from being a great nation?

In the private sector – particularly global enterprises – inertia is overcome by supervision. For instance, global companies operating in the Philippines report to a regional management. This ensures that: (a) while focused locally, (b) they keep an eye on the true north, and (c) that the comfort-zone phenomenon does not set in – which can make them less able to compete.

In the Philippines, we are a standalone entity. In contrast, in the EU, member countries are under the EU’s supervision. This is to ensure that EU standards are adhered to. For example, one of their priority initiatives is the creation of a physical network or highway system. The object is to link every member country, and ensure accessibility to the broader EU market – a fundamental rationale for the creation of the EU. And as a new member gains accession, they tap into the infrastructure funds of the union. Unfortunately, human condition makes generously funded projects open to corruption. And so the EU exercises supervision over its member-countries to make the initiative transparent.

We need to self-police ourselves in the absence of an EU-like structure. For instance, if we prioritize and step up infrastructure development, government must be committed to transparency. The writer has talked about prioritizing three (3) fundamental economic imperatives: (a) basic infrastructure of water, food, power, etc.; (b) strategic industries to drive and enlarge the size of our GDP, and (c) addressing the enablers of/barriers to: competitiveness, corruption and economic freedom.

On the 3rd point, it appears (from a Manila Times article) that “ . . . six key government agencies have been silently reforming themselves, improving the way they have been doing their assigned tasks, and thereby contributing to meeting the MDG (Millennium Development Goals). They are all undertaking the Performance Governance System (PGS), a local adaptation of the Balanced Scorecard applied to the public sector, to track their performance against a set of goals. They will make their performance commitments public on March 25, 2010 at the Public Governance Forum jointly convened by the Institute for Solidarity in Asia (ISA), the National Competitiveness Council and the Development Academy of the Philippines.

“Apolitical government people in the administration and the civil service in these six government agencies are silently working on urgent governance reforms that could no longer wait for the next Filipino president to be sworn into office . . .”

This is great news and a great model. And it is heartening that people and institutions appear dogged in their efforts. More power to them!

Monday, April 5, 2010

The economy and the gift of blessedness

When the writer’s family was winding down their annual winter sojourn in the Philippines – to catch up with family and friends – they packed the inspiration of their Lenten retreat with precious souvenirs from home. Thanks to a family friend who’s taken it upon herself to put them through this periodic stirring experience.

How to reconcile the spiritual and the secular? The foreign investor’s view of the country’s economic performance and potential is mixed at best: while short-term investors participate in our stock market, our foreign direct investments, on the other hand, are below regional norms. We ourselves poked those (irresponsible and greedy) American bankers for celebrating their trillion dollar balance sheets; but being blind to the toxic assets they kept in CDOs, CDSs, etc. – and thus went belly up, because their net worth was effectively negative? (Some even cooked the books to no avail!)

Yet, every time the writer is in the country, he would sense the power of the Filipino’s spirituality. And it is probably why the Filipino keeps a happy disposition – truly a gift.

The country’s economic malaise is finally being perceived more objectively – as a presidential adviser admits to our failure to arrest poverty? And if we assume that the conspiracy theorists are wrong – that we’re not being setup and conditioned to accept a failed election? To be sure, change is never easy – to a person and more so to a country? That’s why Born Again Christians truly attribute their conversion experience to a higher being?

As the Bishop stressed during the retreat, the gift of blessedness must bear fruit. Its absence comes from our rejection of the gift. And there is blame to go around in spades – from government to industry to education to the Church, and of course, Juan de la Cruz, himself? Shrinks will say we need to psyche ourselves up given the enormity of the challenges we face – but we need to go beyond that . . . and step up to the plate? Adam and Eve tried pinning their misstep on Satan but the verdict was: “Out” – take personal responsibility!

We need to admit to more missteps – because to bear fruit we must first properly cultivate the soil and sow the right seed? We can’t confess the sins of our neighbors; or in secular parlance, we can’t keep pointing the blame on our parents or colonizers or enemies? For example, the Vietnamese have embraced the Americans and are today their biggest investors!

But precisely because the gift of blessedness is not man-made, it is not characterized by man’s impatience – or secular assessments coming from the writer or whoever. And the Bishop has a great example: a well respected priest is asked by seminarians if he struggles keeping the seal of confession; and his ready response: my sins are worse than theirs and yet I know I am forgiven, and so are they; and so I forgive and forget.

We may have bungled the last 60 odds years but we know we have been forgiven – notwithstanding the conspiracy theorists, our culture of corruption and whatever else ails us? And as the writer’s family travels on to other parts of the world, he is confident that one day we would be seeking and bearing the fruit of our blessedness. For example, a Manila Times article reads: “The great news is that . . . reforms in . . . six important government agencies have been going on . . .”

And the words of the Bishop will always ring true: Meekness is not laziness. It is not lack of backbone. It is not just tolerance. It is not false gentleness. Mourning is grieving for others – to hunger and thirst for justice and righteousness, for their sake.

Thursday, April 1, 2010

Prioritize or perish?

It appears we are beginning to put reality on the table – when a presidential adviser admits to our inability to arrest poverty. We may be inching forward to objectivity? It is not only poverty that we need to confront. The greater the complexity of the undertaking the greater is the need to prioritize and focus. It’s counterintuitive – that’s what large and complex enterprises learn all the time! For instance, we must prioritize in order to provide Juan de la Cruz the basics of water, food and power. We must prioritize our strategic industries in order to invest at the right levels and get the bang for the buck. We must prioritize our efforts to truly address our rankings in competitiveness and corruption and economic freedom.

Beyond objectivity, we must establish clarity of purpose – as opposed to falling on our instinct of inclusion. Dispersing our efforts reduces our ability to overcome major challenges. For instance, our GDP per person is miniscule – and thus, the only option for us is to prioritize and focus. (We instinctively come up with a laundry list of initiatives yet over several decades they weren’t done – i.e., we missed the true north or the genius of the (GC) Greatest Commandments!)

If the ultimate in man’s quest, salvation, is attained via the simple GC, how can man’s lesser endeavors demand more? In world-class enterprises they incessantly drill two things to attain sustainability or economies of scale: (a) in a new venture, the object is critical mass; and once it is reached, (b) the object becomes dominance. Both demand discipline and a forward-looking mindset. To achieve critical mass the focus is on margins; and to attain dominance, the focus is leadership. From follower one must become a leader. A leader is always two steps ahead, and comes up with compelling products with healthy margins. Ergo: you satisfy one (a) and you satisfy the other (b) and vice-versa.

Having just spent several weeks in the country, the writer wondered if we have forgotten that even the Creator focused on one thing at a time, instead of using his magic wand and cramming the work of ‘seven days into one’? Everyone wants to get ahead or a piece of the action – and given our culture of inclusion (just say the magic word, ‘paki’), we struggle to prioritize? The developed parts of the world point to respect for time and space as facilitating their ability to prioritize and focus. And poorer Vietnam is showing us the way to accelerate agriculture development (they’re going hi-tech and we’re still talking small scale?) by shifting from follower to leader, for instance; and our neighbors have shown us how to be economic tigers.

Many years ago the writer visited Papua New Guinea on business. There were tales of tribal conflicts he had heard but the very first village he visited gave him a sense of how civilization was advancing. He was introduced to the village chieftain and sat next to him as school children proudly demonstrated their culture through dance and music. And after the show the writer’s group distributed product samples. The people were in their best behavior, patiently waiting for their turn.

If these village people could queue and patiently wait for their turn, they probably wouldn’t engage in tribal conflicts, having learned to respect time and space? This was running in the writer’s mind – because the hotel where he stayed was fenced and well secured though over cocktails and dinner community personalities were naturally warm and friendly. As the writer traveled to different parts of the world, it would occur to him how much people have learned to respect time and space. And the more they did, the more progressive they were.

At a Lenten retreat the writer received a little prayer card and on the back was written “12 little things Filipinos can do to help the country”. The first reads: “Follow traffic rules. Follow the law.” It’s probably a call that it’s time to focus on the basics and our strategic industries, and respect time and space?

Tuesday, March 30, 2010

Should a primitive economy . . . based . . . on . . . endemic corruption accompany us into the future?

That’s Mikhail Gorbachev speaking in an editorial opinion in the International Herald Tribune (March 13-14, 2010). Clearly Gorbachev does not subscribe to “false gentleness” and probably mirrors the challenge of the Beatitudes. In our case, without having to speak, the international media has had a field day given our endemic corruption – and why foreign investors favor our neighbors?

Gorbachev continues: “Russia once again faces the challenge of change . . . The Soviet system . . . condemned our country to inferiority . . . Our main mistake was acting too late to reform the Communist Party. The Party . . . soon became a hindrance to moving forward . . . We made other mistakes too . . . we lost sight of the economy, and people never forgave us for the shortages of everyday items and the lines for essential goods . . . Many people were plunged into poverty; the income gap became one of the widest in the world . . . Russia [lost] its industrial base, its economy became fully dependent on export of oil and natural gas . . . Stabilizing the country cannot be the only or the final goal. Russia needs development and modernization . . . in a global, interdependent world . . . The country has not moved closer to that goal . . . Russia will only advance with confidence if it follows a democratic path . . . The independence of the courts has been thrown into question . . . If the people are to feel and act like citizens, there is only one prescription: democracy, the rule of law and an open and honest dialogue between the government and the people.”

There are lots we need to correct but the first thing probably is to toss false gentleness. The best way to impress the outside world and attract investors is to do something concrete – for example, to fully engage the global economy, recognizing its imperfections . . . yet others have gained much from it? As our finance and accounting professions taught us, the key when evaluating an undertaking is to assess its net worth; not to just focus on either its strengths (assets) or weaknesses (liabilities).

The writer spends the most time in Eastern Europe and can relate to what Gorbachev is saying. Yet, if we Filipinos pause and reflect on his words, chances are we will see the Philippines in the same light as Gorbachev sees Russia?

The writer is at the Taipei airport, on a layover. Many years ago he did business in the country and realized that the Taiwanese could use Filipino expertise – beyond respecting the balance sheet and managing working capital especially in manufacturing, they also needed to raise marketing and sales efficiency and effectiveness. And so he had a couple of Filipinos mentor their Taiwanese colleagues.

At that time Taiwan had already progressed their manufacturing expertise (e.g., light industries – their bicycles were commanding premium pricing in North American, with technology developed in partnership with the West) and were moving into high-technology like electronics. Still, they embraced every opportunity to advance every facet of industry.

Talking up one’s strengths (like CEOs Fuld and O’Neal of Lehman and Merrill Lynch, respectively, did) could engender disaster. It takes a big person, as FDR admonished the Americans, to admit one’s shortcomings and commit to change. And Gorbachev, decades later, is still heeding the advice?

Friday, March 26, 2010

Bishop explains the Beatitudes

Meekness is not laziness. It is not lack of backbone. It is not just tolerance. It is not false gentleness. Mourning is not confined to mourning one’s loss. It is as much as grieving for others – to hunger and thirst for justice and righteousness, for their sake.

A group of ladies was so moved that even before the Lenten retreat ended they started gearing up – to invite the candidates in the presidential election (and their running mates) to a recollection on the Beatitudes.

If we’re blessed, if the country is blessed, why are we where we are? Have we been receptive of our gift of blessedness? Then where is the fruit? In the lesson of the fig tree we are warned: not to repeat history, that those who were led to the ‘promised land’ could loss it because they were like the fig tree . . . that did not bear fruit!

So where is the fruit? Where is the water in our taps? Where is the light that we’re supposed to get at the flick of the switch? Where is the rice, the coffee, the sugar? Where are the jobs?

But there are the new roads – and who are winning the contracts on these new roads? Are they world-class contractors that can teach us 21st century technology?

The ladies should probably, after inviting the politicians, invite industry too – to a recollection on the Beatitudes with the Bishop. It takes two to tango. Where is the fruit of our economic output – with the few? But even our few aren’t world-class? We don’t develop world-class enterprises – because competitiveness is not what’s driving their businesses? Is it all about influence peddling – i.e., focus on the local market, win kudos for ‘love of country’ and then seal the deal via influence? There are honest-to-goodness enterprises but the reality is 10% own 80% of our wealth – thus the 10% could just be unwittingly scratching each other’s back or why we’re perpetuating a hierarchical culture?

It is heartening that San Miguel may sell more of their beer holdings to Kirin; with the latter looking at pushing growth in Southeast Asia. If San Miguel’s vision is to be a broad-based investor like Warren Buffett (as opposed to striving for competitive advantage in every business they operate like a GE), then that is a good first step – partnering with entities that have a greater potential to attain competitive advantage. Competitive advantage is what world-class enterprises focus on, in order to sustain their businesses, not influence peddling!

It is encouraging that Nestlé is developing state-of-the-art coffee-raising technology in Davao; and they will work with local farmers as partners. In an earlier blog article, the writer talked about Nestlé’s investment in R&D, that they’re investing twice the industry norm. Enterprises like them are ideal partners – because of their capability to assist us override the learning curve: from the basics of agriculture all the way up to higher valued-added branded packaged goods, thus attain competitiveness. (Note: the writer is not connected with either San Miguel or Nestlé.)

Who else should the ladies rope in to listen to the Bishop and reflect on the Beatitudes . . . so that as a country we would seek and bear the fruit of our blessedness?

Monday, March 22, 2010

A ghost of a chance

“Agriculture sector to go hi-tech”, reads a Vietnamese local news report. Vietnam is gearing up to: “Phase out small-scale agriculture through the introduction of new technologies that are expected to result in higher yields and more competitive farm produce . . . part of a well-thought out effort to industrialize the agriculture sector . . . and reach specific ambitious economic targets that call for encouraging businesses in identified strategic provinces . . .

“A service network to cater for hi-tech agriculture will be established, with brokerage, technical consultancy, equipment supply and product consumption support services . . . Incentives will be offered to businesses covering R&D, importation of technology, human resources overseas training . . . Lands will be optimally sized . . . Government will erect specific infrastructure needs in targeted provinces . . . It acknowledges past failed pilot efforts due to inefficiencies; and because the country’s bio-technology is underdeveloped, among others. The new initiative will link hi-tech agriculture and bio-technology . . .“ (The writer read this after he had traveled to Cambodia, and was told of one of Pol Pot’s failures: the commune system.)

How can we top that? By industrializing agriculture too yet being two steps ahead, i.e., going to agri-business, and all the way to branded, packaged goods! (But is grains importation taking our eye away from the ball, holding our agriculture industry hostage and thus failing – thankfully, media is at least keeping the issue alive?)

The Vietnam government is likewise eyeing bureaucracy and targeting 5,400 or 30% of administrative procedures affecting individuals and enterprises, including regulations that conflict with each other. They expect to improve efficiency and reduce costs by 30%. The Vietnamese are clear thinkers, defining their goals in precise terms, and as importantly, are learning from their mistakes? And are driven?

“I will die if I don’t work hard. This week is Chinese New Year but I can’t tell you not to visit Hanoi during our holiday. My family and friends respect me though for working on a holiday. I own a motorbike like most everyone; it will take me 7 years before I can buy a car. As students we’re young and ignorant and don’t take education seriously. But now that I need to work in order to survive, I aspire to be like a Malaysian and then like a Singaporean, sooner than later.”

Millions of Filipino OFWs can relate to this young Vietnamese. Yet, there are visitors to the Philippines who wonder: outside the OFWs and our professionals and entrepreneurs, are we as driven as others? The writer has been asked a few times how unemployed Filipinos could survive. In jest he would say that we’re like the Italians and the Irish, and lately unemployed young Americans who have gone back home. Given our extended family structure, it is not an issue at all! But what are they really asking: is one of our greatest assets, our liability as well, i.e., too much of a good thing is actually bad?

And OFW remittances are too much of a good thing, i.e., our robust foreign exchange reserves and stable currency are masking the deep hole we’re in – while giving the powers-that-be the means to exercise influence-peddling with impunity, e.g., grains importation? And why the ADB says we’re suffering from Dutch Disease – not unlike building our house upon the sand?

An op-ed columnist summarizes how we view change: “this is in fact a society that is resistant to change”! That is what the writer dreads most about the country – because resistance to change is the common denominator of failed economies, i.e., they’re broke but didn’t fix them! Like it’s the 21st century and we’re still tolerating rotating brownouts? Fool us once and you’re a fool; fool us twice and we’re the fools!