Wednesday, July 16, 2014

Is it Francis not Padre Damaso?

“CBCP chief seeks ‘Pope Francis’ approach vs. corruption,” Joel Locsin/LBG, GMA News, 5th July 2014. “Perhaps, we can reconsider our approach at solving the cancer of Philippine society which is graft and corruption by talking more about the beauty of integrity and honesty rather constantly denouncing the evil that we experience," he said.

“. . . The Church should follow the example of Pope Francis, who he said has shaken the old belief systems about spiritual shepherding . . . The Pope has so far ‘slowly moved the Church from being a dogmatic, self-engrossed and authoritative sick institution to being a gentle, outreaching, compassionate and persuasive Church through the power of love and mercy . . . Besides . . . the Church loses perspective when it loses its humility, and this makes the Church reactive. When we lose humility, we lose perspective. When we lose perspective, we also become too reactive. When we become too reactive, we become less effective and less credible as pastors. The loss of humility in Church ministry can be very costly.”

Was that what Rizal said over a century ago – because Juan de la Cruz has taken his religion to mean subservience? Does the church need to do more to undo over a century of blind obedience? For example, have we unwittingly created a very soft culture that breeds tyranny? If we equate the West as being the opposite, the following ought to give us pose – even in America leaders must go out of their way to fight blind obedience:  “I’ve seen the best of management and the absolute worst of management.” [Kevin Tracey, on Putting It Together (After Taking It Apart), Adam Bryant, Corner Office, The New York Times, 5th July 2014; Tracey is the president and CEO of the Feinstein Institute for Medical Research of the North Shore-LIJ Health System.]

“The worst is when the team fears the leader, so when someone sees something going wrong, they’re afraid to point it out. I’ve also seen the best. It’s about clearly stating the purpose and asking people how they’re doing and really listening if someone needs something different . . . If the operating team can accommodate the needs of that person without deviating from the plan, that person will be a better member of the team . . . How do [I] hire? My favorite question is, “What do you want to do?” If you don’t know what you want to do, you’re letting chance dictate your future. Then I look for patterns in their life that show they’ve conceived of a plan in the past and accomplished it.” 

Sadly, in the Philippines, despite our being well-informed and contemporaneous in our knowledge of business and management, our leadership model is still reflective of our culture? And it mirrors that of our hierarchical church? And so transparency is not foremost in our value system; and, not surprisingly, political patronage, oligarchy and corruption continue to haunt us? And I am always reminded of our reality every time our extended family (here in the US) has a reunion. As I would explain it to my wife, I am convinced the Pinoy way of life indeed is not easy even to tweak. And I would point her to the way my son-in-law (who is American) interacts with his father. In our culture, it would be taken as disrespect – because my son-in-law would express his views as though he was talking to a friend and it didn’t matter if his father was in agreement. If we think that is unique to America, I also see it even in Eastern Europe, kids “arguing with their parents – even their grandparents.”

Should individual rights not be encumbered in a democratic environment – whether family or church? And did Rizal think so as he observed the Age of Enlightenment while in Europe . . . and thus the need for him to create Padre Damaso?

Does the church need to refocus – and why Francis and now the CBCP seek a different approach? A nation must focus on nation-building or the common good, for example, and that can’t be adverse to the church? If indeed we value life, should we value the rights of every person, including the right to speak their minds? [Valuing life does not begin and end with RH?] Especially given that person is made in the image and likeness of The Creator? The bottom line: subservience was meant for another time? Do we as a nation need to do more?

And among us mortals in the secular world, do we as a nation need to focus on nation building? “Give to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s and to God which are God’s.” “There are people who have lost their focus, not because they have not put on their glasses, but because they do not know how important focus is. This is a weakness that must be addressed. Here is the key:  Focus is not a skill; it is a decision.” [Focus is intentional, Francis J. Kong, Business Matters (Beyond the bottom line), The Philippine Star, 6th July 2014]

“Focus is intentional, it is not accidental. Not focusing meant that the person is embarking on a perpetual sense of useless energy. You need to decide to focus. Life is not a digital game you play on your tablet, that every time you feel bored, you swipe it away. Focus is discipline in action. Be like the champion archers, they do not aim at the bull’s eye, they aim and focus at the center of the bull’s eye. Every successful business person I have met is skilled in the art of focusing.”

“While our graduate education programs are needed to produce good teachers and good managers, it is critical to analyze how the country’s graduate education system can best serve the needs of the country to meet its development goals.” [PHL graduate programs should address country’s development needs–study, Cai U. Ordinario, Business Mirror, 6th Jul 2014]

And the West has recognized similar needs as well: to focus the education system on producing graduates that can communicate, work in teams and be creative. In the private sector to communicate means more than reciting in class or writing a paper. It means, for instance, getting the rest of the team to buy into an idea. And it is not just any idea, but creative ideas – and they come from the diversity of the members of the team where there is no pulling rank. And creative ideas are not art for art’s sake. There ought to be a context – to reinforce the enterprise’s role as a contributing member of society, meaning, it is sustainable and not a flash in the pan, and for the common good.

Of course, if the church could be a “sick institution” (see above re CBCP), all the more private enterprise? And that is precisely why development means to be egalitarian not hierarchical – where transparency rules, not tyranny? Beyond the fight against the pork barrel, should the bishops in fact address political patronage and oligarchy, the two sides of the same coin that we’ve nurtured, i.e., a cacique culture? But has the church given it a wink a nod? And is it the cancer that Rizal saw over a hundred years ago?

The Jews learned very early on that 300 tenets were not the context but the Great Commandment? What is the context for us Pinoys? If it is deference to hierarchy then we shall be regional laggards, not just now . . . but even beyond – precisely why Rizal had to dramatize his argument via Padre Damaso?

Thursday, July 10, 2014

More than AEC 2015, how do we face the 21st century?

The good news is we’re not alone facing the challenge. “All over the world, formal education systematically suppresses creative thinking and flexibility. National strategies to raise standards in education are making matters worse because they’re rooted in an old model of economic development and a narrow view of intelligence. For economic, cultural and political reasons, creativity should be promoted systematically at all levels of education, alongside literacy and numeracy. . . . Companies now face an unusual crisis in graduate recruitment. It’s not that there aren’t enough graduates to go around, it’s that too many of them can’t communicate, work in teams or think creatively.” [Jim Burke, Reimagining English: The seven personae of the future; English Journal 99.2 (2009), pp 12-15, The National Council of Teachers of English]

“Creative thinking involves calling into question the assumptions underlying our customary, habitual ways of thinking and acting and then being ready to think and act differently on the basis of the critical questioning.”[http://www.umich.edu/~elements/probsolv/strategy/crit-n-creat.htm] In the same material, one would read the components of critical thinking as follows: “(a) identifying and challenging assumptions; (b) recognizing the importance of context; (c) imagining and exploring alternatives; and (d) developing reflective skepticism; [and that] creative thinkers would consider rejecting standardized formats for problem solving; [and] have an interest in a wide range of related and divergent fields; take multiple perspectives on a problem; use trial-and-error methods in their experimentation; have a future orientation; and have self-confidence and trust in their own judgment.”

How do we reconcile that in a hierarchical system and structure like ours? A survey of PricewaterhouseCoopers spells out“the most important ingredients to successful innovation: (1) The right culture to foster and support innovation; (2) Strong visionary leadership; (3) Willingness to challenge norms and take risks; (4) Ability to capture ideas throughout the organization; (5) Capacity and capability for creativity.” [Business Innovation Done Right, http://econintersect.com/, 26th Sept 2013]

While the above speaks to business organizations, culture is a fundamental given if innovation is to be fostered and supported. And thus beyond the imperatives of roads and bridges or infrastructure, for example, economies and nations need to innovate with their products and services in order to be competitive. The days of comparative advantage are over; it is now about competitive advantage? For example, Filipinos speak English and are conscientious workers and so OFW remittances are the backbone of our economy. But as we now know, our neighbors lead us across the board in terms of competitiveness.

And critical to competitiveness and innovation is strong visionary leadership. Chancellor Angela Merkel comes to mind. Instead of succumbing to populist demands, she had the vision to lead Germany to embrace RE or renewable energy, for example. The average German was cursing her; that she was insensitive – as their utility bills spiked up – and promised she wasn't to lead Germany for long. She’s still around!

“We have our work cut out for us when it comes to navigating complex problems, in large part because we are hard-wired to seek certainty as quickly as possible. The research of decision scientists reveals that our best strategy for tackling these problems is to harness cognitive diversity, because groups do better than individuals, including those with the highest IQs. Complex problems are characterized by confusing systems of causal interactions; untangling these requires multiple different points of view. Diversity . . . trumps ability.” [The Hidden Enemy of Productive Conversations, Ted Cadsby, Harvard Business Review, 4th July 2014]

“But the benefits of cognitive diversity do not materialize automatically — they have to be engineered. And groups are just as vulnerable as individuals to the number one enemy of productive thinking: path dependence. Path dependence is the tendency for things (such as events, belief systems, personalities, evolution, and conversations) to unfold in ways that are constrained by the parameters of the path they are on. It represents the enormous influence of the past on the future.”

“When thinking does not stray from certain parameters, creativity and results are sacrificed. The more we’re aware of the paths that constrain our thinking, the less captive we are to them. To generate deeper and more creative insights, leaders have to push a group’s thinking beyond the narrow paths that otherwise take hold. High quality conversations require stewardship. Leaders need to create and encourage constructive dissent to open up new possibilities, expand insight, and generate better decisions.”

“Constructive dissent depends on two conditions: genuine independence of thought and constructive engagement between team members. Leaders must encourage their teams to speak freely and independently, to correct one another’s errors and build on good ideas, and to allow the insights of others to deepen their own thinking. Flexible, expansive conversations that resist path-dependent thinking are the best (and only) way to navigate an increasingly complex world. And fostering them is one of the most important jobs of our leaders.”

“No matter what your age or your life path . . . it is not too late or too egotistical or too selfish or too silly to work on your creativity. . . . I have come to believe that creativity is our true nature, that blocks are an unnatural thwarting of a process at once as normal and as miraculous as the blossoming of a flower at the end of a slender green stem.” [How to Get Out of Your Own Way and Unblock the “Spiritual Electricity” of Creative Flow, Maria Popova, Brain pickings, 4th July 2014]

The first time my Eastern European friends and I talked about how to win in the market place eleven years ago, they thought it was insane. “We don’t even have a plan for the balance of the day. We’re Bulgarians; we take it as it comes. We never talked about the future. All we knew was we had our daily provisions of bread and a handful of vegetables courtesy of our Communist masters – and not much else. And so we learned how to create different salads out of the few veggies, raise livestock and other vegetables and make rakia (an alcoholic beverage from fermented fruit) at home.”

Two days after I got back from New York recently, I attended a business review session between a business unit and a regional team, and they proudly presented the product development plans for several years. It was just the middle of the current year and I was asking about the year’s numbers. And the regional manager talked about their three focused countries and their respective business dynamics, with the largest one firing on all cylinders. And then the business unit manager grinning from ear-to-ear discussed the progress of the expansion of the manufacturing facilities “because we have to be ahead of the curve.” These ex-socialists were born and raised under Communist rule; and today they talk like Fortune 500 managers.

Even socialism/communism wasn’t cast in stone?

Monday, July 7, 2014

Spinning wheels

“Singapore first, the Philippines last.” [Fragile: Survey shows how precarious the Philippine state still is, Benjamin E. Diokno, Core, Business World, 2nd July 2014] Have we been reduced to spinning wheels? Does it have to do with “Pinoy abilidad”? That instinctively we like to take advantage of the low-hanging fruit while making “pa pogi” or declaring victory? And while OFW remittances are the biggest example and represent our own “Dutch disease” we have many others? “The 2014 Fragile State Index (FSI) results suggest that the Philippines, compared to its neighboring countries and the rest of the world, has a long way to go before it becomes truly competitive globally.”

“Looking at countries closest to home, the Philippines has remained the most fragile among ASEAN-6 countries. This bloc includes Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines, Singapore, Thailand and Vietnam. The ranking among ASEAN-6 countries has not changed since four years ago: Singapore first, the Philippines last. This poor ranking is especially true in terms of poverty and income decline and public services. The latter includes public infrastructure.”

“The short-term perspective of the current approach to Philippine tourism (there are virtually no initiatives or forecasts beyond 2016) might be successful in boosting the industry quickly, but in doing so mortgages the economic future of tourism communities.” [Tourism: Mortgaging the country’s economic future, Ben D. Kritz, The Manila Times, 2nd July 2014]

“To the extent that he has influence over the broader approach to tourism policy—an extent that may actually be limited, given that the physical development of tourism infrastructure and destinations relies on other agencies and the private sector—Secretary Jimenez should prioritize sustainability over volume. That means extending tourism plans by 20 or 30 years; matching target numbers to stages of development, and designing those developmental stages to be re-purposed effectively after the tourists disappear.”

“After all, those who need to be “included” in the “inclusive growth” Jimenez and his boss in MalacaƱang say tourism can provide will still need to be included, whether there are any tourists or not; there is no point where policymakers can declare the job done. The present approach, while admirable for its fervor, suggests the government is not clear on that point, and that’s something that needs to change if tourism is to be truly successful in the Philippines.”

As marketers know it, there is such a thing as the “marketing mix” and in the case of tourism, the first element or the product is PHL itself – and beyond its God-given natural beauty, the product includes infrastructure. In other words, promotion (which is another element of the mix; the others being pricing and place) or advertising cannot make up on a sustained basis for an inferior product. We can employ big data and analytics to optimize the marketing mix; but as Jonathan Ive of Apple would recall Steve Jobs, “focus on product,” was what he learned directly from Jobs. [Jonathan Ive on Apple’s Design Process and Product Philosophy, Brian X. Chen and Matt Richtel, The New York Times, 16th June 2014]

Does it remind us of CCT (Conditional Cash Transfer) or DAP (Disbursement Acceleration Program)? They are like the low-hanging fruit which in the private sector equate to tactical efforts – but they’re part of a broader strategic perspective that would connect the dots? In other words, short-term tactical efforts, logical as they may be, are not the be-all and end-all!“Steve Jobs talked about [connecting the dots] in his famous commencement speech. He said that creativity is just connecting the dots. Creative thinkers produce ideas by finding the relationship between facts.” [7 Habits of Highly Creative Minds, Antoinette Seaman, business.tutsplus.com, 4th July 2012]

“The once vaunted “Filipino First” policy has morphed into a “Rich Filipino First” policy, as much of the country’s resources and wealth have been gobbled up by economic oligarchs. Simply stated, the remarkable economic growth has not been inclusive, bypassing the poor and the unemployed.” [Strategies for inclusive development, Robert Evangelista, Philippine Daily Inquirer, 29th June 2014]

“While it is true that our chronic twin problems of poverty and unemployment may not be solved overnight, their alleviation and mitigation can be considerably hastened with innovative, stimulating and productive transformational strategies that will significantly uplift the lives of all Filipinos, including the poorest of the poor. Our people cannot afford to wait for remedies that are agonizingly slow in coming. They need solutions with immediate and powerful impact.”

“The constitutions of other countries are wisely silent on economic issues and, thus, they retain great flexibility in enacting economic laws responsive to the demands of the rapidly changing times. But not the Philippines, where we have disregarded or overlooked this principle on constitution-making, for our fundamental law expressly embodies ultranationalistic economic provisions limiting foreign ownership and investments in vital sectors of the economy.”

“As a consequence, the Philippines has harvested the bitter fruits of this monumental constitutional blunder. Because of these misguided economic policies deeply embedded in our Constitution, for decades the Philippines has lagged far behind its Asean-5 neighbors in economic growth, foreign investments, job generation and poverty alleviation.”

And here it gets more confusing; it’s not simply reconciling the short- and the long-term but we have to dig deeper into our beliefs? At the end of the day, do we want to be an island unto ourselves notwithstanding the risk, if not damage, from being isolated from the bigger world – as in perpetuating a cacique culture that is parochial, hierarchical and paternalistic while undermining PHL’s competitiveness?

In other words, what is the context of our worldview that we seem to accept the label regional laggards matter-of-factly? We can’t run the nation that is PHL to the ground?  And it isn’t compatible with our sense that we Pinoys are creative? “Creative thinking involves calling into question the assumptions underlying our customary, habitual ways of thinking and acting and then being ready to think and act differently on the basis of the critical questioning.”[http://www.umich.edu/~elements/probsolv/strategy/crit-n-creat.htm]

And settling for the low-hanging fruit does not equate to creativity? And critical thinking presupposes “identifying and challenging assumptions; recognizing the importance of context; imagining and exploring alternatives; and developing reflective skepticism.” [ibid.]

It’s too bad, so sad if we’ve been reduced to spinning wheels – finding no traction in our pursuit of the low-hanging fruit?

Friday, July 4, 2014

Politics, religion, education and oligarchy

“The history of constitution making in our country was the preserve of the ilustrado, the elite because, as the reasoning goes, they are the experts. We now know it is not true. They may be good in grammar, how to articulate lofty thoughts, make laws – all – but little of what really matters to make society with varying interests work. We see all the traces today of the mistake of relying solely on experts.” [FROM A DISTANCE, Carmen N. Pedrosa, The Philippine Star, 29th June 2014]

The “ilustrado” – they were supposed to bring us prosperity? Hierarchy's unwritten rule, unfortunately, says: “see no evil, hear no evil, speak no evil”? In short, politicians, the church, educators and oligarchy make up the elite class . . . and all of us that are part of the network – and together we’ve been running the country? The exception being Juan de la Cruz – and he had to suffer the folly?

“A prominent personality who built a reputation for integrity, only to sell to the highest bidder in his twilight years, reportedly said he had to make sure he would leave enough to ensure that his children would live in comfort when he's no longer around. I'm sure that attitude is not rare in this country. Such “public servants” are helped along by the weakness of our judicial system, which not only moves slowly but is also extremely vulnerable to political influence because, let's face it, members of the judiciary owe their appointments and promotions to the political establishment.” [Ana Marie Pamintuan, Remember ZTE (?), Sketches, The Philippine Star, 2nd July 2014]

Sadly, instead of stepping up to the plate of reality, we believe more of the same would turn the big ship that is PHL around? It is not about politics but good governance. It is not about religion but faith. It is not about education per se but producing citizens that are able to perform the tasks of a nation. It is not about oligarchy and our cacique masters but an egalitarian ethos that engenders creativity in the pursuit of the common good.

We are a failed nation not because this blog says so but it’s out in the open – i.e., we’re a witness to the collective outcome that our institutions have churned out? And it is not for lack of ideas; our “kuro-kuro” culture generates tons of them – except that we keep crying over spilt milk? “It’s not about the hand but how we play it.”

In other words, we have to grow up? “[T]here is a darker side to adolescence that, until now, was poorly understood: a surge during teenage years in anxiety and fearfulness. Largely because of a quirk of brain development, adolescents, on average, experience more anxiety and fear and have a harder time learning how not to be afraid than either children or adults. Different regions and circuits of the brain mature at very different rates. It turns out that the brain circuit for processing fear — the amygdala — is precocious and develops way ahead of the prefrontal cortex, the seat of reasoning and executive control. This means that adolescents have a brain that is wired with an enhanced capacity for fear and anxiety, but is relatively underdeveloped when it comes to calm reasoning.” [Why teenagers act crazy, Richard A. Friedman, The New York Times, 28th June 2014]

Why do we seem to be frozen in time? Is it because of too much religion and very little faith? Not surprisingly, Cardinal Tagle is calling us to examine our culture – as in misunderstanding our faith and what family is about? Neither time nor the world is at a standstill – and so even once invaders like Japan can be our friends? Indeed there are no rules, only principles? If former enemies can be friends why can’t we live the principle – that is, to look at the future instead of the past? Is it because of too much religion that we seem to live in the past – that progress or science is bad, for example? And we wonder why beyond the jeepney we have nothing to show? And why were the Jews told to toss 300 tenets and embrace The Great Commandment? 

Translation: We are adolescents because we haven’t learned to prioritize beyond family – aka “crab mentality”? The evidence: we can’t put up a modern airport; we can’t put up such basics as power and roads and bridges – etcetera – yet we haven’t managed land use either while abusing the environment and denuding our forests? What more of industry which takes more doing? In short, we haven't prioritized and erected the building blocks of an economy and a nation! But we proudly ensured that our children would live in comfort? See above re “public servants.”

And yet because of our fatalism we believe we are today’s Asia’s economic miracle? We are amongst the least developed nations in the region that investors are looking at us. But that doesn’t mean they will bet on us. The PHL ecosystem cannot handle heavy investments, if we can attract them in the first place – the collective outcome that our institutions have churned out? When there are “no tracks, bullet trains are inutile.” Even in the US northeast where they considered a bullet-train system between Washington DC and Boston, they couldn’t do it because the tracks were primitive.

Until our institutions reboot or reset PHL, we shall be confined in the cellar – left in the dark ages?

Wednesday, July 2, 2014

Stepping up to the plate III

“We like to think we're rational human beings. In fact, we are prone to hundreds of proven biases that cause us to think and act irrationally, and even thinking we're rational despite evidence of irrationality in others is known as blind spot bias.” [58 Cognitive biases that screw up everything we do, Drake Baer and Gus Lubin, Business Insider, 18th June 2014]

Is there something to read between the lines in the following? “Cielito Habito, chief of party of the USAID Trade Related Assistance for Development (TRADE) Project and former Philippine economic planning chief, said some deterrents to FDI persist in the Philippines, such as constitutional restrictions on foreign ownership, the high cost of power, infrastructure inadequacies, cumbersome trade transaction processes, and governance hurdles including at the local government levels.” [PH still lags in FDI inflows as Asean integration nears, The Manila Times, 24th June 2014]

“’In a second analysis by UNCTAD, the investment incentives mostly focus on economic performance objectives, and less on sustainable development . . . There is a need to better align incentives to sustainable development goals (SDGs),’ Habito said. The SDGs are intended to galvanize action worldwide through concrete targets for the 2015 to 2030 period for poverty reduction, food security, human health and education, climate change mitigation, and a range of other objectives across the economic, social and environmental pillars,” Habito said. Habito added that inadequate public finances will need to be supplemented by private sector investments, which are currently very low.”

If investment or the lack of it in fact underpins our underdevelopment and our inability to focus on sustainable development, what would it take for us to have a bias for investment? Is the reason we seem unable to address the challenge of investment that we’re not foursquare behind it? And so international institutions continue to hammer us on the “constitutional restrictions on foreign ownership, the high cost of power, infrastructure inadequacies, cumbersome trade transaction processes, and governance hurdles including at the local government levels?”

Do they in fact represent our “blind-spot bias”? And so we’d look elsewhere like targeting rural poverty or farms-to-market roads? But they are the low-hanging fruit – similar to promoting OFW remittances that have translated into our own “Dutch disease”? Put another way, they are the inverse of the Pareto principle?

If we are to look at agribusiness, for example and develop a roadmap, it has to be in the context of agribusiness being a critical building block of PHL economy – not a livelihood or charity initiative. And it demands for us to first define what the endpoint is [note that the typical linear thinking process starts with the input, not “with the end in view,” or clearly establishing what success means or what the endpoint is like], as in making PHL a major player in agribusiness. (Sadly, for decades, major agricultural products were in the back pockets of vested interests – and we wonder why PHL agriculture is outdated? And they were laughing their way to the bank because of our complicity, i.e., our protectionist bias or how we would define nationalism? And we have reams and reams of research to justify our worldview? No wonder Lee Kuan Yew and Mahathir Mohamad both would choose to give unsolicited advice given our parochialism? Let’s grant, for the sake of argument, that they are ignorant especially of our culture, but a medical historian, in 1971, noted that in the history of man, “the experience of the ignorant has routed the wisdom of the learned,” from The New York Times, Who made the pacifier, Dashka Slater, 20th June 2014. Sadly, Singapore and Malaysia have the better experience in development?)

If we are to be a major agribusiness player, what products must be our focus – i.e., like in the private sector, our product portfolio must be comprised of products that will give us the biggest bang for the buck. And that presupposes that products are segmented consistent with their architecture: from basic to high or very high value-added in order to optimize returns. That can only come if we've figured out the regional and global markets for these products. How do we then penetrate these markets? What mechanism must we put in place to tap and win these markets? (And doing road shows or even attending trade fairs is too passive; marketing efforts must be proactive.)

How do we produce these products, beyond the requisite farms, what industries must we erect? What are the mandatory inputs at the farm-end and at the industry-end? How do we assemble these inputs and pull them together to attain synergy? Do we need advanced if not state-of-the-art technology to sustain competitiveness? What about foreign technology and investment? [Note that the inputs come later in the process, i.e., a roadmap is akin to a GPS; we first set where we want to be, not the other way round. And we have visionaries to thank and the psychologists that figured out how their minds worked.]

But back to infrastructure: “[I]nfrastructure development in the country remains a major hindrance to the country’s development amid the planned regional integration.” [AEC offers trade opportunities but infra bottleneck remains, Mayvelin U. Caraballo, The Manila Times, 24th June 2014]

“Philippines is the third lowest in overall quality of infrastructure in the Asean region based on the Global Competitiveness Report 2013-2014. To fully take advantage of the opportunities of an integrated Asean, investments in infrastructure are needed particularly in the aviation industry . . . NAIA 1 (Ninoy Aquino International Airport Terminal 1) served 7.5 million passengers in 2012, but its capacity is only 5.5 million passengers . . . emphasizing [the necessity] to boost infrastructure spending to 5 percent of GDP by 2016.”

“One commentary described the Italian situation as a government that is slow, inept and bureaucratic; where it takes years or decades to get anything through the courts. Italians have displayed a marvelous aptitude for getting things done in spite of government, not because of it.” [Philippines: The Italy of Asia (?), The Business Mirror Editorial, 24th June 2014]

“THERE are some interesting similarities between Italy and the Philippines. Obviously the Roman Catholic Church runs deep into both countries’ culture, and many people feel the Church has or attempts to have too much influence over secular affairs. Italy, like the Philippines, is a country where the people are tied to their provincial roots.”

“Matteo Renzi, from the left-leaning Democratic Party, at 39 years old, became Italy’s youngest Italian Prime Minister in February . . . For the last 10 years, his one objective has been the top spot to bring genuine structural reform to Italy. Renzi has convinced many people that reform is possible. Specifically, he wants to eliminate their Senate and streamline the decision-making process in the house of Parliament. This will require a change in the Italian constitution. He believes that the current system discourages foreign direct investment . . . He wants to reform the judicial process to allow court cases to be resolved in a realistic timeframe.”

“This is not just all talk and campaign slogans. Renzi is willing, because of the parliamentary system, to have his government face election after election if necessary to allow the people to decide if his reforms are welcomed or not . . . Renzi does not see those who object to all of his plans as the opposition but as an opportunity to forge alliances toward a common goal. He has a detailed vision to fix what he sees as a broken system of government. Maybe the Philippines is not the Italy of Asia, after all.”

In other words, could we ever come up with a detailed vision to fix . . . what is a broken PHL – and elect a leadership like Renzi? Could we ever step up to the plate? Could Juan de la Cruz ever figure out his blind-spot bias?

Monday, June 30, 2014

“Where is the grand design?”

“Show me the product . . . Show me the ingenuity.” Tough questions . . . that were hurled at Tim Cook: “Tim Cook, Making Apple His Own,” Matt Richtel and Brian X. Chen, The New York Times, 15th June 2014. And they apply to major undertakings, be it an enterprise or an economy or a nation? In the case of PHL, how many times did we say we had the grand design for our economic development? And we even would proudly claim ingenuity? But “Show me the product” – it is beyond a 7% GDP growth, it has to be sustainable over many years, i.e., it will take us at least a generation to attain developed economy status? But where is the product or products? Where is the grand design?

There won’t be? Read Philippines instead of Ukraine and there is the answer: “Corruption in Ukraine did not begin with Mr. Yanukovych—nor will it end with him. Weak institutions, low morale, and an underdeveloped sense of public service have made everyone from judges to traffic police liable to corruption over Ukraine’s entire post-Soviet history. Murky privatization . . . in the mid-1990s created a class of oligarchs who came to exercise outsized influence on politics and business.” [The curse of corruption in Ukraine, The Economist, 14th June 2014]

Why haven’t we developed R&D or ST&I (Science, Technology and Innovation), for example? Who needs them when we abdicate and cede the playing field to oligarchy and our cacique masters? “The fact that there is nobody in the Philippines who regulates urban planning has been great for Ayala Land because we are probably the only company there that has the scale financially to take on large plots of land . . . By developing big tracts of land, we become the government; we control and manage everything. We are the mayors and the governors of the communities that we develop and we do not relinquish this responsibility to the government.” [Ayala rules, Jojo Robles, Manila Standard Today, 13th June 2014]

Why can’t we be a free market or eliminate the restrictive economic provisions of the Constitution? Because we won’t develop the 21st century culture if we remain beholden to and proud of our archaic model, as in “Ayala rules”? “One of the values of things I learned absolutely directly from Steve was the whole issue of focus. What are we focusing on: focus on product. I wish I could do a better job in communicating this truth here, which is when you really are focused on the product, that’s not a platitude. When that truly is your reason for coming into the studio, is just to try to make the very best product you can, when that is exclusive of everything else, it’s remarkable how insignificant or unimportant a lot of other stuff becomes. Titles or organizational structures, that’s not the lens through which we see our peers.” [Jonathan Ive on Apple’s Design Process and Product Philosophy, Brian X. Chen and Matt Richtel, The New York Times, 16th June 2014]

“Fifty years ago there was a revolution in psychology which changed the way we think about the mind. The ‘cognitive revolution’ inspired psychologists to start thinking of the mind as a kind of organic computer, rather than as an impenetrable black box which would never be understood. This metaphor has motivated psychologists to investigate the software central to our everyday functioning, opening the way to insights into how we think, reason, learn, remember and produce language.”How Thinking Works: 10 Brilliant Cognitive Psychology Studies Everyone Should Know, PsyBlog, 27th Jan 2014]

“Without experts the human race would be sunk. But what is it about how experts think which lets them achieve breakthroughs which we can all enjoy? The answer is in how experts think about problems, compared with novices. That’s what Chi et al. (1981) found when they compared how experts and novices represented physics problems. Novices tended to get stuck thinking about the surface details of the problem whereas experts saw the underlying principles that were operating.”

“There are no rules only principles,” I reminded the young marketing manager that my Eastern European friends assigned to North America. And we were in Montreal and had meetings with our partners and the advertising agency and visited countless stores. The fellow is a quant [and was the brand manager of and played a major role in growing the company’s biggest brand; and negotiated media deals in different countries] and as a student he represented their country twice in the math world competition. And he continues to be a “card-bearing communist” – he keeps the ID he had as a kid and I would tell him John Paul II must also have had his as a young boy. I was explaining the principle of partnership – and its inherent character, transparency – referencing our Canadian representatives, to respond to the question he posed: “Should they know how much we’re investing in developing this market?” Born and raised under Communist rule, it wasn't a surprise where he was coming from.

And in the Philippines are we: (a) “stuck thinking about the surface details of . . . problems [instead of] . . . the underlying principles that [are] operating” and (b) do we carry the instincts of distrust given our culture of impunity and political patronage? And they have undermined our efforts to move the country forward? And so we have all the right to ask, if indeed we have a grand design for PHL, “Where is it?”

“We like to think we're rational human beings. In fact, we are prone to hundreds of proven biases that cause us to think and act irrationally, and even thinking we're rational despite evidence of irrationality in others is known as blind spot bias.” [58 Cognitive biases that screw up everything we do, Drake Baer and Gus Lubin, Business Insider, 18th June 2014]

Thursday, June 26, 2014

Survival of the fittest . . .

We are against . . . and it sounds kind and compassionate? Or are we Pinoys unknowingly rationalizing our assumptions? For example, we don’t truly embrace free market because it is unkind to the weak? [60-40 ownership rule hit anew, Lenie Lectura, Business Mirror, 17th June 2014. “British companies are seriously looking at pouring more money into the Philippines, provided the government will relax the restrictions on foreign ownership of companies in certain industries, the United Kingdom (UK) mission to Manila said.”] But if we push that as far as we can, what is reality? It is preserving the old order that was archaic, as in man didn’t know any better? And which was in fact the age of ‘survival of the fittest’?

Translation: The old order was hierarchical where the lion was king of the jungle. In more modern times they were the fat cats and in old Russia they were the tsars who in reality were beholden to a bigger monster, oligarchy? But nature compensates; for example, oligarchy thrived in cacique cultures creating a mirage of an equilibrium courtesy of paternalism – and thus explains the longevity of oligarchy?

Is that one way of capturing the reality of PHL? But there is another element that has contributed to our archaic model? And it’s no other than the church? And it precisely has successfully mirrored a mirage of equilibrium courtesy of compassion to the poor and the weak? Of course, it isn’t a secret except that it would take a Francis to call a spade a spade?

Having been born and raised in an environment where we defer to hierarchy – either our cacique masters or the church – did we Pinoys miss learning responsibility? While our kuro-kuro culture could be loud and reaches far and wide, at the end of the day, no one is responsible? For instance, a culture of impunity can’t be nurtured if we the Filipino people are non-participants – as in see no evil, hear no evil and speak no evil? And the same applies to political patronage? “. . . Filipinos in general must engage in soul-searching and in communal examination of consciences to discern the status of the Filipino culture and how it can be ‘purified’ . . . I just wish that we would set it in a wider context, not only in the politicians but of the whole country and the whole Filipino culture . . .” [Parents plant seeds of corruption–Tagle, Jocelyn R. Uy, Philippine Daily Inquirer, 11th June 2014]

In fairness, it isn't confined to us Pinoys. It is human nature to take the path of least resistance or to be subsumed by the status quo because it represents a comfort zone. It is a great lesson in the art or challenge of execution. Or why “the best laid plans of mice and men often go astray.”

“I really want to figure out their personality. If someone has left a few jobs, I’ll ask why they left. If people are complaining too much, then you start seeing either an attitude of, ‘When things happen, it’s not really me; it’s the world around me.’ Or maybe they’ll talk instead about things in a way that clearly says, ‘Listen, there are always circumstances, but you make your own destiny; you make your own choices.’” [Victor Allis, CEO of Quintiq (a planning software company); Stumped? Invoke the 5-Minute Rule, Adam Bryant, Corner Office, The New York Times, 7th June 2014]

“I’m looking for someone in a leadership position who feels that when someone deals you a hand, sometimes it’s a good hand, and sometimes it’s a bad hand. But it’s not about the hand. It’s how you play it . . . It takes a little while to figure it out, but you’re trying to understand, at their core, how they behave in life. Will they be a team player? Will they be the person who can handle some adversity and actually likes the challenge? Those are the most important characteristics.”

If we are to turn a big ship like PHL even a fraction of a degree, we need leadership that recognizes that “it's not about the hand. It's how you play it.” And leadership doesn't mean one individual. Leadership is the ones at the top of the enterprise or economy or nation. If we apply Pareto's 80-20 rule, they are the 20 that generate the bulk of the results. And in PHL they are the elite class. If in the US the conservatives seem unable to put up a big umbrella to embrace a far larger agenda or one that matters to mainstream America, in PHL the elite class has successfully raised a truly big umbrella. Thus despite the differences between and amongst its different elements, the elite class has preserved the status quo? 

And so what makes up the commonality? First is it's hierarchical. And it starts when we send our children to exclusive schools; and they're Catholic, obviously. And a school bus is so “commoner” so to be chauffeured is preferred; correction, the prim and proper way. And between the gated-community and the country club that make up their milieu, they learn early in life there is such a thing as a network amongst the elite class; and so it’s not uncommon that they go together on holidays to the latest “talk-of-the-town” destinations locally or abroad? What about college; it has to be in an Ivy, where else?

And so what do the local media cover? The world of the elite class, what else? But we're compassionate and so we must fight poverty? The elite class is the fittest and so they survive – with plenty to spare the downtrodden – despite PHL's standing in the region and in the world, the nation equated to OFWs that cover the world, near and far. And that has given us a very robust foreign exchange reserves and thus the ability to manage our finances better.

Admittedly we are thankful for our OFWs' efforts because they are the direct and proximate cause of our better economic footing. But because of this good fortune, we contracted our own Dutch disease, unable to assemble and put together the building blocks of a sustainable and inclusive economy? Because we have yet to truly commit and deliver on good governance and world-class infrastructure and a free market and a regionally (and globally) competitive industry?

And while on the one hand we instinctively reject such straightforward initiatives since we believe a complex challenge demands a complex solution, on the other hand we readily want to paint a positive prognosis? For example, that PHL GDP in 2014 will continue to grow at a robust clip – albeit slower than last year – conveniently forgetting that we are deficient in the above critical areas: of good governance and free market and thus the negative impact on investment, infrastructure development and competitiveness, among others. And that it would take us at least a generation to approximate a developed economy.

And in the meantime we have yet to recognize the imperatives of: (a) setting and espousing a vision, (b) leadership and (c) focus; while caught up in our archaic model which in our heart of hearts we wish to preserve? We have an abundance of smart people jostling and offering the silver bullet to overcome PHL underdevelopment and poverty but do we need visionaries too that can set a crystal clear goal (which could be as simple as to be a developed economy?) that would rally Juan de la Cruz?

Still, a vision demands leadership and focus; and focus is something that we need to dig from our toolkit – as in the wisdom behind ‘The Great Commandment’ or Pareto’s 80-20 rule. But instead, perhaps unwittingly, we've been preoccupied raising the progress and development attained by our neighbors as a bogeyman in order to preserve our self-esteem, if not our rank in PHL hierarchy?