Friday, January 13, 2023

Do we see “green shoots” out of the BOI?

“We develop exports through FDI, not internally. Look at Vietnam. Look at Thailand. Factories put up by foreign investors produce the export products coming from our neighboring countries. It could be our country eventually (that can serve) as the production base for our export market, Trade Secretary Alfredo E. Pascual said.

“The pandemic disruptions in China and the Russia-Ukraine war have roiled global supply chains, leading many manufacturers to reconsider their options in choosing an Asian base of operations.

“Mr. Pascual said foreign investors will help provide the Philippines with technology, capital, and new markets.

“The foreign investors we are trying to attract here have a built-in market and already have the technology. It is a matter of setting up the factory here and employing our people. That’s the approach that I am pushing. We integrate trade, industry, and investment,” Mr. Pascual said.” [“Foreign investors’ choice of Asian manufacturing base seen as critical for PHL export prospects,” Revin Mikhael D. Ochave, BusinessWorld, 8th Jan 2023]

Let’s hold it right there.

Recall the force field theory in managing change: (a) exploit the driving forces and (b) right the restraining ones. And green shoots can blossom into driving forces, meaning the Philippine elite and chattering classes must step up to the plate.

Recall that preeminent economist Ciel Habito raised the crux of our challenge. Our export revenues are a mere fraction compared to our neighbors.

Recall, too, that media pillars Boo Chanco and Tony Lopez broke the initiative of tycoon Ramon Ang to develop Bulacan beyond the Bulacan airport, mirror the Pearl River Delta Economic Zone, and generate incremental exports of $200 billion. That will match the performance of our neighbors.

If we want to internalize the power of the force field theory, we may want to pause and ponder that we see a trifecta in front of us, courtesy of Messrs. Pascual, Habito, and Ang.

Consider that we have paid lip service to the mantra: Create jobs to address poverty and “inclusion.” The private sector expresses it as “the fiscal side of the enterprise is not the driver of the enterprise.”

For the enterprise we call the Philippines, we must learn to think outside the box and embrace forward-, lateral, and creative thinking. And toss the fixed mindset that has defined our approach to economic development — and nation-building.

Said differently, we can’t embrace “insanity” lest we sink deeper into the abyss.

Back in 2015, we thought we saw green shoots. But the blog was skeptical. A quote from the posting eight years ago: “We cannot assess manufacturing’s potential by simply assuming FDIs will move from China to PHL. We need to focus on where the most significant bang is and understand the competitive drivers. For example, Japanese manufacturers that left China chose Indonesia over PHL.”

In other words, the blog has raised the challenge of reinventing Juan de la Cruz since its inception 14 years ago.

Why? Because “change” is not a walk in the park. There is no free lunch. It takes “self-governance” for a nation like ours to overcome our instincts. We are parochial and insular. We value hierarchy and paternalism and rely on political patronage and oligarchy; ours is a culture of impunity.

And we are being true to form, “In the most impoverished countries, there will be less support for social change in a country that arguably needs it the most. It explains the “system justification theory.”

Let’s hold it right there and drill down on “self-government.”

“The Pilgrims knew they had to do something quickly; otherwise, every man, woman, and family would be for themselves. While still on board the ship, a group of 41 men signed the Mayflower Compact, in which they agreed to join together in a “civil body politic.” This document would become the foundation of the new colony’s government. Signed on 11th Nov 1620, the Mayflower Compact was the first document to establish self-government in the New World.” [History.com]

The crab mentality is the human condition. And worse, governments can be corrupt.

“Self-governance is also associated with political contexts in which a population or demographic becomes independent from colonial rule, absolute government, absolute monarchy, or any government they perceive does not adequately represent them.

“Henry David Thoreau was a major proponent of self-rule in place of “immoral” governments.

“In ancient Greek philosophy, Plato posits the concept of self-mastery as the ability to be one’s master; he states that individuals or groups cannot achieve freedom unless they govern their pleasures and desires and instead will be in a state of enslavement.

“John Locke furthers this principle in that genuine freedom requires cognitive self-discipline and self-government and that man’s capacity for this is the source of all “freedom.”

“In this sense, freedom is not a possession but an action. Locke proposes that rationality is the key to true agency and autonomy and that political governance is the outcome of governing one’s judgment. His political philosophy was a prominent influence on Immanuel Kant and was later taken up in part by the United States Founding Fathers.” [Wikipedia]

Freedom is beyond one’s rights. It is not a possession but an action.

In other words, we must toss the Philippine caste system and the value of hierarchy and paternalism. Privileges and entitlements aren’t the given. We can’t be both Juan Tamad and Bondying rolled into one.

Mr. Pascual has his job cut out for him. Recall that the blog often discusses “horizontal leadership” as an expression of “self-governance.” He must now engage both the public and private sectors to edify them that, as demonstrated by our neighbors, rapid economic development cum nation-building is a reality and not a pipe dream.

“We integrate trade, industry, and investment.” If by that we mean we must create the requisite ecosystem to drive rapid economic development, then we are on the right track.

Again, from an earlier posting: “Ramon Ang’s Bulacan initiative, beyond the Bulacan airport, must mirror the Pearl River Delta Economic Zone ecosystem and generate “incremental” exports of $200 billion. That will pave the way for the Philippines to match the export revenues of our neighbors. And which is how Vietnam eliminated poverty.

“As the blog has raised, the BOI must be in the crosshairs to assume this challenge and toss our historical models in crafting investment incentives. 

“We have over 400 export processing zones under the PEZA. Yet, we generate the most negligible export revenues. How many more export processing zones are we contemplating, given the NEDA 5-year development plan?

“Sadly, we can’t wrap our heads around Pareto and distinguish the “vital few” from the “trivial many.

“What do we keep missing? We’re stuck with addressing jobs, poverty, and inclusion and pursuing quantitative tools but no forward, lateral, and creative thinking.

“We have no experience designing and assembling the requisite “ecosystem” to equip us to navigate the journey from poverty to prosperity. Moreover, as we take for granted our caste system, we won’t slay the dragon of political patronage and oligarchy.”

The good news is that Mr. Pascual is upending our inherent inward-looking bias, “We develop exports through FDI, not internally. Look at Vietnam. Look at Thailand.”

Recall that the blog distinguishes (a) logical yet linear and incremental thinking and (b) forward, lateral, and creative thinking.

It will not be easy for Juan de la Cruz to upend our caste system. Moreover, we carry much baggage from the past.

And here is where Maslow’s hierarchy of needs comes in – from physiological to self-actualization. And it is the bedrock of innovation.

Yet, we won’t embrace innovation and global competitiveness if we can’t embrace forward thinking.

Recall how I explained freedom, democracy, and the free market to my Eastern European friends. They are not about rules but principles.

Even the wife wondered how these people could move forward: What are we doing in this godforsaken place?

Answer: We are a subset of this dynamic universe in constant motion and expansion.

“Like Europeans, the eastern woodland Indians of North America engaged in near-constant fighting during the centuries before first contact. Native American warfare differed dramatically from European hostilities regarding its roots, aims, and nature.

“Old World wars of the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries, such as the Spanish Reconquista or the Hapsburg-Valois Wars, were costly, large-scale affairs. They had religious or dynastic origins, produced comparatively high casualties, and fought to achieve territorial or economic gains.

“Indians fought these wars for several reasons. First, blood feuds were a way for Native Americans to avenge the deaths of kin or tribe members murdered by other Indians. Second, mourning wars gave young men the opportunity to earn the prestige needed to become respected and influential members of their tribe. Third, taking captives satisfied demographic needs by providing a source of replacements for a tribe's deceased members. Fourth, mourning wars fulfilled a spiritual and psychological function by easing grief, providing a means for coping with death, and restoring to the community the spiritual strength believed lost through the death of a clan member. Finally, blood feuds provided a steady source of captives for some Native Americans’ ritual sacrifices.” [Native American Warfare in the East: Mourning Wars | Encyclopedia.com]

“The first European colonization wave began with Castilian and Portuguese conquests and explorations and primarily involved the European colonization of the Americas, though it also included the establishment of European colonies in India and Maritime Southeast Asia.

“During this period, European interests in Africa primarily focused on establishing trading posts there, particularly for the African slave trade. The wave ended with the British annexation of the Kingdom of Kandy in 1815; and the founding of Singapore in 1819.

“The period in which much of the first wave of European colonization (and other exploratory ventures) occurred is often labeled the Age of Discovery.

“A later primary phase of European colonization, which started in the late 19th century and primarily focused on Africa and Asia, is known as the period of New Imperialism.

“Religious zeal played a large role in Spanish and Portuguese overseas activities. While the Pope was a political power, the Church also sent missionaries to convert the indigenous peoples of other continents to the Catholic faith. Thus, the 1455 Papal Bull Romanus Pontifex granted the Portuguese all lands behind Cape Bojador and allowed them to reduce pagans and other “enemies of Christ” to perpetual slavery.” [Wikipedia]

In other words, the Christian faith we proudly embrace is the other side – of the coin – known as New Imperialism.

But then again, we are a subset of this dynamic universe in constant motion and expansion.

“Most tribal wars were fought for the essential resources: goods, territory, and women. These reproduction-enhancing resources prompted our ancestors to fight to pass down their family genes. According to a new study, an exciting pattern occurred with war as a driving force for survival.

“People with certain warrior-like traits were more likely to engage in and win “wars” and then pass their warrior genes down to their children, which – on an evolutionary timescale – made their tribe even more warrior-like. In short, humans seem to have become more aggressive over time due to war’s essential benefits.

“In their study, Stanford University scientists Laurent Lehmann and Marcus Feldman have presented a model showing that aggressive traits in males may have evolved as an adaptation to limited reproductive resources. Because tribal war serves as a method for appropriating territory and women, war may have driven the evolution of these traits.

“The scientists use the term “belligerence” to refer to a trait that increases the probability that the person’s tribe will attack another tribe. Likewise, “bravery” refers to a trait that increases the probability that the person’s tribe will win a war.

“Lehmann and Feldman demonstrate in their model that belligerence and bravery continue to evolve through the male line genetically. When one tribe conquers another, males in the conquering group mate with females in the conquered group and pass the warrior traits to their male offspring.” [Tribal war drove human evolution of aggression (phys.org)]

In other words, if there is a hierarchy of human needs, humankind also evolved – will continue to “evolve.”

Recall that the blog distinguishes (a) logical yet linear and incremental thinking and (b) forward, lateral, and creative thinking.

Do we see “green shoots” out of the BOI?

“We develop exports through FDI, not internally. Look at Vietnam. Look at Thailand. Factories put up by foreign investors produce the export products coming from our neighboring countries. It could be our country eventually (that can serve) as the production base for our export market, Trade Secretary Alfredo E. Pascual said.

Mr. Pascual has his job cut out for him. Recall that the blog often discusses “horizontal leadership” as an expression of “self-governance.” He must now engage both the public and private sectors to edify them that, as demonstrated by our neighbors, rapid economic development cum nation-building is a reality and not a pipe dream.

“We integrate trade, industry, and investment.” If by that we mean we must create the requisite ecosystem to drive rapid economic development, then we are on the right track.

In other words, we must toss the Philippine caste system and the value of hierarchy and paternalism. Privileges and entitlements aren’t the given. We can’t be both Juan Tamad and Bondying rolled into one.

It will not be easy for Juan de la Cruz to upend our caste system. Moreover, we carry much baggage from the past. See above; humankind has evolved – and will continue to “evolve.”

History must equip us to navigate the future, not turn back the hands of time.

And here is where Maslow’s hierarchy of needs comes in — from physiological to self-actualization. And it is the bedrock of innovation.

Yet, we won’t embrace innovation and global competitiveness if we can’t embrace forward thinking.

Gising bayan!

Sunday, January 8, 2023

Embracing the status quo

“In developing countries, where group inequalities are most evident, there is a more excellent justification of the status quo. In the most impoverished areas of Bolivia, children (aged 10–15) who were members of low-status groups legitimized the Bolivian government as sufficiently meeting the needs of the people more so than children from high-status groups.

“In other words, in the most impoverished countries, there will be less support for social change in a country that arguably needs it the most. It explains the “system justification theory.” [Wikipedia]

Look at how we moved from the basket case of Asia to the perennial regional laggard.

Then consider: Our economic managers are still exuding hubris instead of giving credit to Juan de la Cruz – for sacrificing and toiling overseas, away from families, despite the attendant social ills. [In the private sector, heads roll when an enterprise is the basket case or regional laggard.]

In other words, our income streams come from the OFW remittances and call centers. Instead of taking transparency for granted, it behooves our economic managers and legislators to monitor for the benefit of Juan de la Cruz, where we are in the GPS.

Specifically, where are we income stream-wise? Where do we want to be, i.e., how are we creating other income streams given that we are not generating the required revenues as an economy and are standing on the shoulders of Juan de la Cruz?

It is called analytics. Investors won’t bet on a company that cannot demonstrate sustained growth and profitability in the private sector. The fiscal side of the enterprise is not the driver of the enterprise.

Let’s say it one more time, in the private sector, heads roll when the enterprise is the basket case or regional laggard. Hubris is out of place. 

Recall how the blog defines our instincts, reflected in the Philippine caste system: We are parochial and insular. We value hierarchy and paternalism and rely on political patronage and oligarchy; ours is a culture of impunity.

“System-justifying beliefs serve a psychologically palliative function. It proposes that people have several underlying needs, which vary from individual to individual, which can be satisfied by the defense and justification of the status quo, even when the system may be disadvantageous to certain people.”

Rizal was not a psychologist, but over a century ago, he averred that we submit to tyranny because we love it. It’s called a defense mechanism.

“The need for order and stability, and thus resistance to change or alternatives, for example, can motivate individuals to see the status quo as good, legitimate, and even desirable.”

We even have the expression, “Walang basagan ng trip.” In other words, because of the need for “harmony,” we let the next person do their thing. You can do your thing, and I will do mine. Is that why it comes down to the crab mentality?

Yet, it’s not just Juan de la Cruz that justifies the status quo.

“According to system justification theory, people desire not only to hold favorable attitudes about themselves (ego-justification) and the groups to which they belong (group-justification.) They also hold positive attitudes about the overarching social structure they are entwined to and find themselves obligated to (system-justification).”

Recall that the wife rejected the offer of my former company to relocate to New York. We were in the Philippine establishment, and rank has its privileges.

But then we criticize the democratic system because it is a Western import. Of course, the Greeks invented it. Yet, no two democratic systems are alike because they are self-government.

Do we take self-government for granted because it demands personal responsibility? And personal responsibility is absent in a caste system?

The story of the Pilgrims reflects how “self-government” can come about. It’s a lesson in how humankind, even a small group of 41, can be the nucleus that would pave the way for today’s hegemon. As a Ukrainian friend intimated over the Christmas holidays, “Thanks to the Americans, we will win this war.”

Yet even Americans can’t afford to take “self-government” for granted. I am with my wife in Puerto Rico, taking a respite from the harsh winter, and why we missed the Philippines during the pandemic. The good news is that we will fly to Manila shortly.

If the Ukrainians, an ocean away and beyond, are thankful to the Americans, the Puerto Ricans haven’t recovered fully from successive hurricanes. Puerto Rico is a US territory with limited representation in Washington. The question of statehood is classic kicking the can down the road.

The Americans have more trials and tribulations to demonstrate that “self-government” is not a walk in the park.

“Some 100 people, seeking religious freedom in the New World, set sail from England on the Mayflower in September 1620. That November, the ship landed on the shores of Cape Cod in present-day Massachusetts. The scouting party found Plymouth Harbor, where they would form the first permanent settlement of Europeans in New England. These original settlers of Plymouth Colony are known as the Pilgrim Fathers or simply as the Pilgrims.

“The group that set out from Plymouth, in southwestern England, in September 1620 included 35 members of a radical Puritan faction known as the English Separatist Church. In 1607, after illegally breaking from the Church of England, the Separatists settled in the Netherlands, first in Amsterdam and later in the town of Leiden, where they remained for the next decade under the relatively lenient Dutch laws.

“Due to economic difficulties, as well as fears that they would lose their English language and heritage, they began to make plans to settle in the New World. Their intended destination was a region near the Hudson River, which at the time was part of the already established colony of Virginia. In 1620, the would-be settlers joined a London stock company that would finance their trip aboard the Mayflower, a three-masted merchant ship. A smaller vessel, the Speedwell, had initially accompanied the Mayflower and carried some of the travelers, but it proved unseaworthy and returned to port by September.

“Some of the most notable passengers on the Mayflower included Myles Standish, a professional soldier who would become the military leader of the new colony, and William Bradford, a leader of the Separatist congregation. Bradford was the author of “Of Plymouth Plantation,” his account of the Mayflower voyage and the founding of Plymouth Colony.

“Rough seas and storms prevented the Mayflower from reaching their initial destination in Virginia. After 65 days, the ship reached Cape Cod’s shores, anchoring on Provincetown Harbor in mid-November. Discord ensued before the would-be colonists even left the ship. The passengers who were not separatists–referred to as “strangers” by their more doctrinaire peers—argued the Virginia Company contract was void since the Mayflower had landed outside Virginia Company territory. William Bradford later wrote, “several strangers made discontented and mutinous speeches.”

“The Pilgrims knew they had to do something quickly; otherwise, every man, woman, and family would be for themselves. While still on board the ship, a group of 41 men signed the Mayflower Compact, in which they agreed to join together in a “civil body politic.” This document would become the foundation of the new colony's government. Signed on 11th Nov 1620, the Mayflower Compact was the first document to establish self-government in the New World.” [History.com]

Can we, in the Philippine elite and chattering classes, take inspiration from the 41 men that signed the Mayflower Compact and commit to embracing “self-government”?

In other words, how do we upend the Philippine caste system?

Consider: We are parochial and insular. We value hierarchy and paternalism and rely on political patronage and oligarchy; our culture is impunity.

Let’s start with overturning parochialism and insularity.

Here’s a quote from an earlier posting: “Why does the blog beat the Pearl River Delta Economic Zone no end? Because unless our technocrats and economic managers embrace serious benchmarking against the economic miracles delivered by our neighbors, we will be left reinventing the wheel and throwing decades upon decades of progress.

“In other words, the Asian Tigers demonstrated to the world that rapid economic development cum nation-building is a reality, not a pipedream.

What about our reliance on political patronage and oligarchy? Given the context of our challenge, to be a first-world economy, we must move beyond binary thinking.

Again, from an earlier posting: “Ramon Ang’s Bulacan initiative, beyond the Bulacan airport, must mirror the Pearl River Delta Economic Zone ecosystem and generate “incremental” exports of $200 billion. That will pave the way for the Philippines to match the export revenues of our neighbors. And which is how Vietnam eliminated poverty.

“As the blog has raised, the BOI must be in the crosshairs to assume this challenge and toss our historical models in crafting investment incentives. 

“And recall, the blog challenged the Philippine president to invite the most prominent investors, especially in technology like TMCC, Samsung, and Apple, personally and pick their brains on how the Philippines can match if not outdo the neighbors’ efforts. Mahathir did this by creating a tech advisory group that included Bill Gates.

“And last November, Zelensky of Ukraine signed an investment partnership with the CEO of BlackRock CEO Larry Fink. BlackRock is the world’s largest asset manager.

Consider: “We have over 400 export processing zones under the PEZA. Yet, we generate the most negligible export revenues. How many more export processing zones are we contemplating, given the NEDA 5-year development plan?

“Sadly, we can’t wrap our heads around Pareto and distinguish the “vital few” from the “trivial many.”

“What are we glossing over in the upbeat tenor of NEDA? For example, Vietnam overtook the Philippines’ GDP per capita in 2020. Moreover, they put poverty in the rearview mirror. How? By taking the playbook of the once Asian Tigers, “beg for foreign money and technology.”

“Yet, we are still forging along the same path reliant on the OFW remittances and call centers, including the 6.0 to 7.0 percent growth metric.

“In other words, we’re stuck in logical yet linear and incremental thinking. And that is despite decades of underperformance as an economy.”

Aside from NEDA, there is the Central Bank (BSP). What about the BSP?

“The BSP said it remains steadfast in its commitment to its primary mandate of sustaining price and financial stability and stands ready to take all necessary action to bring inflation to within the 2-4 percent government target band over the medium term.

“Governor Medalla has indicated his preference to maintain a 100 basis-point (one percentage point) differential with the Fed rate. 

“This may be the most difficult time since I joined the Monetary Board more than a decade ago,” he told economic journalists in November. 

“We are facing exceedingly tough challenges. There is the overly aggressive response of the US Fed [US Federal Reserve].

“Then, we also have the Ukraine-Russia conflict, which along with domestic supply issues, pushed up the prices of oil and non-oil commodities. That has pushed inflation to the center of mainstream consciousness.”

“These challenges are indeed tough, but the Philippines will pull through. We have done so in past crises and will do it again.” [“BSP will beat inflation,” Tony Lopez, Virtual Reality, manilastandard.net, 6th Jan 2023]

What are we missing from the above narrative? Where did the Philippines stand as an economy before the pandemic? See above; when and why did Vietnam overtake us?

Benchmark. Benchmark. Benchmark.

Why did our neighbors leave us in the dust one after the other? They embraced the imperative to benchmark.

In other words, progress does not have to start from square one each time. Given our caste system, looking outward is not our default impulse. Instead, do we like to keep reinventing the wheel, demonstrating hubris or insanity? 

“System-justifying beliefs serve a psychologically palliative function. It proposes that people have several underlying needs, which vary from individual to individual, which can be satisfied by the defense and justification of the status quo, even when the system may be disadvantageous to certain people.”

“According to system justification theory, people desire not only to hold favorable attitudes about themselves (ego-justification) and the groups to which they belong (group-justification.) They also hold positive attitudes about the overarching social structure they are entwined to and find themselves obligated to (system-justification).”

And so we defer to those higher up in the hierarchy, like technocrats.

Here’s a quote from an earlier posting: “The Rice Tariffication Law came with much fanfare as a response to food security. Yet, it is another example of logical yet linear and incremental thinking that we associate with technocracy. It is, again, merely a tool and, at best, a stop-gap measure to protect Juan de la Cruz.”

Let’s hold it right there.

Why does the blog often speak to “tools” associated with technocracy?

Consider: “The International Rice Research Institute (IRRI) is an international agricultural research and training organization with its headquarters in Los Baños, Laguna, in the Philippines, and offices in seventeen countries. IRRI is known for developing rice varieties that contributed to the Green Revolution in the 1960s, preempting Asia’s famine.

“The institute, established in 1960, aims to reduce poverty and hunger, improve the health of rice farmers and consumers, and ensure environmental sustainability of rice farming. It advances its mission through collaborative research, partnerships, and strengthening the national agricultural research and extension systems of the countries IRRI works in.”

If there is one enormous advantage – or tool – we have behind our rice industry, it is the IRRI. 

Why did we fail to leverage such an outstanding tool? And then we expected the Rice Tariffication Law to be the answer to food security?

Let’s drill that down.

Look at the impulse demonstrated by Vietnam. They looked outward to IRRI and exploited it as a crucial resource to elevate the competitiveness of their rice industry. And Vietnam today is a significant exporter.

On the other hand, we ignored IRRI going decades yet proudly touted the Rice Tariffication Law. 

Why does the blog keep raising the distinctions between the “real world and the academic world”?

Or why did my former Fortune 500 company buy technology outside when we had over a thousand scientists?

That is also why the blog is critical of the Philippine Competition Commission. It is an essential tool but toothless in an oligarchic economy.

Our actions reveal an inherent disadvantage, our instincts reflected in the Philippine caste system.

Why does the blog keep rehashing experiences with my former Fortune 500 company and Eastern European friends?

I came from a third-world economy and country, yet they even offered me citizenship. Why? They realized I was pursuing the “common good” – or the imperative of designing and assembling the requisite “ecosystem” to navigate mediocrity to excellence. They did not put hierarchy ahead of the common good.

In other words, the 21st century demands innovation and global competitiveness.

Let’s hold it right there. 

As a third-world economy, we don’t appreciate that wealthy nations are middle-class economies because we associate wealth with gated communities, if not the elite. And those are the metrics that manifest the inequality in an oligarchic economy like ours. That is why we are resentful.

Wealthy nations are “developed economies” where innovations address human needs, thus raising people’s well-being. Yet, they don’t come gratis; otherwise, the undertaking won’t be sustainable.

And the more innovations raise people’s well-being, the more adherents they gain across nations and continents. The best example would be medical care and why the contemporary lifespan is more extended than generations ago.

Moreover, innovation today is democratizing knowledge.

And it goes full circle, i.e., innovation and global competitiveness democratize economic development and nation-building, with Vietnam as the latest example. Because they acquired this simple knowledge from the neighbors, they “beg for foreign money and technology.”

The bottom line: The pursuit of innovation and global competitiveness is the real-world expression of the common good. Yet, given the dynamism of this universe, the challenge won’t cease. Unsurprisingly, Covid mutated into another variant.

Conversely, “in developing countries, where group inequalities are most evident, there is a more excellent justification of the status quo.” Why? Because the values of hierarchy and paternalism sufficiently meet the needs of the people – and why we celebrate the 6%-7% GDP growth metric even when we’ve moved from the basket case of Asia to the perennial regional laggard.

Can we, in the Philippine elite and chattering classes, take inspiration from the 41 men that signed the Mayflower Compact and commit to embracing “self-government”?

In other words, how do we upend the Philippine caste system?

Our economic managers are still exuding hubris instead of giving credit to Juan de la Cruz – for sacrificing and toiling overseas, away from families, despite the attendant social ills. [In the private sector, heads roll when an enterprise is the basket case or regional laggard.]

Gising bayan! 

Wednesday, January 4, 2023

Half-full or half-empty?

Let’s hear from NEDA: “Director-General and Economic Planning Secretary Arsenio Balisacan expressed confidence that Gross National Income (GNI) would improve sufficiently so that by 2025, the Philippines could be upper to a middle-income economy. That will be a remarkable achievement. The Philippines has been classified as a lower middle-income country since the World Bank produced its classification scheme – whether internally in the early 1980s or as officially published since 1989.

“In essence, the NEDA points out, the PDP’s over-arching objective is the revitalization of job creation and poverty reduction and the country’s return to its high-growth trajectory following more than two years of an economic slump brought on by the Covid-19 pandemic.

“The new five-year plan follows the framework of Ambisyon 2040, the country’s long-term development plan established in 2015. The government seeks to achieve the following in 2023: GDP growth target of 6.0 to 7.0 percent; Inflation and food inflation maintained at 2.5 to 4.5 percent in 2023 and 2.0 to 4.0 percent from 2024 to 2028; narrowing of national government debt-to-GDP ratio from 63.7 percent this year to 48 to 53 percent by 2028.” [Manila Bulletin, 2nd Jan 2023]

What are we glossing over in the upbeat tenor of NEDA? For example, Vietnam overtook the Philippines’ GDP per capita in 2020. Moreover, they put poverty in the rearview mirror. How? By taking the playbook of the once Asian Tigers, “beg for foreign money and technology.”

Yet, we are still forging along the same path reliant on the OFW remittances and call centers, including the 6.0 to 7.0 percent growth metric.

In other words, we’re stuck in logical yet linear and incremental thinking. And that is despite decades of underperformance as an economy.

Consider: “We need the outright removal of the restrictive economic provisions to be more competitive and attractive to foreign investors. Liberalizing the distribution and transmission of electricity will help lower power costs and improve energy efficiency through increased competition. Doing the same for seaports would increase the Philippines’ trade logistics efficiency.

“To do this, both houses of Congress can pass a joint and concurrent resolution on amending or outright removing restrictive economic provisions in the 1987 Constitution upon a vote of three-fourths of its members. The amendments shall then be valid when ratified by a majority of the votes cast in a plebiscite. Note that we can amend the economic provisions without touching other areas of the Constitution.” [“Improving the Philippine investment climate,” Gary B. Teves, Philippine Daily Inquirer, 31st Dec 2022; Teves served as finance secretary under the Arroyo administration]

But what is the “flavor of the month”?

“THE most-discussed issue on agriculture in the last few days of 2022 was onions, usually a mundane concern, but now a topic big enough to attract national attention. A kilo of onions, the white kind used as a fill-in for burgers and the type with the most culinary use, breached P400 per kilo, which meant two kilos of chicken, or more than the price per kilo of scarce, domestically-produced pork. Meanwhile, another round of price surges for onions looms. Online sellers now quote between P450 and P500 per kilo, excluding delivery charges.” [“In 2022, agriculture sank deeper into the rabbit hole,” By Marlen Ronquillo, The Manila Times, 1st Jan 2023]

“With the country vulnerable to many external headwinds, the government launched a “30 by 30” initiative to produce 30 percent of its nutritional needs by 2030.

“Food security and inflation are related and are growing problems in the Philippines. The national average for food inflation rose from 6.5 percent in August to 7.7 percent in September. Of the food items, the foremost drivers of higher food inflation are sugar, confectionery, and desserts (30.2 percent), corn (26.2 percent), and oils and fats (20.1 percent).

“The big problem is the lack of productivity in our agricultural sector. Farming methods are antiquated, and the economics of agriculture impoverish the farmers while the government focuses on rice.

“According to the Philippine Institute of Development Study or PIDS, with traditional agricultural methods falling short, investing in new technologies is key to transforming the country's livestock, poultry, and dairy (LPD) industries.

“Many investments must be poured into production and process improvements, including technology, equipment, animal inventory, and workforce capacity upgrades, for the agriculture industry to be more competitive.

“Given the inefficiency of the agriculture department, perhaps the entry of big corporations will help increase our level of food security. There is good news. Metro Pacific and San Miguel have launched such projects.” [“Food security,” Boo Chanco, DEMAND AND SUPPLY, The Philippine Star, 2nd Jan 2023.]

In other words, we are in survival mode. And the thought of how Juan de la Cruz can “thrive beyond surviving” is way beyond us. Beggars can’t be choosers.

Juan de la Cruz is at the level of his physiological needs that he can’t see thriving or being self-actualized – or the Philippines is a first-world economy.

Take rice, our staple food. “All estimates point to a 2022 rice importation of at least 3 million metric tons, almost at par with the greed and profit-driven rice importation in 2019, the first year of the Rice Tariffication Law (RTL). Again, we will be the second-biggest rice importer in the world after China, a country that can justify its rice imports because of its 1.4 billion people and role as a “factory to the world.”

“Our record-high rice imports have failed to impact rice prices in a significant way, with today’s rice prices only slightly lower than rice prices pre-RTL. A small group – well-connected rice importers and traders – has been reaping the windfall from the scrapping of the quantitative restrictions on rice and the passage of the RTL.

“The impotence of this law in lowering rice prices for consumers did not prevent the previous government from adding an executive order for more liberalized food imports — rice included — on top of the RTL. Executive Order (EO) 171 further lowered tariffs on rice, corn, coal, and pork.” [Ronquillo, op. cit.]

In other words, the Rice Tariffication Law came with much fanfare as a response to food security. Yet, it is another example of logical yet linear and incremental thinking that we associate with technocracy. It is, again, merely a tool and, at best, a stop-gap measure to protect Juan, de la Cruz.

Why does the blog beat the Pearl River Delta Economic Zone no end? Because unless our technocrats and economic managers embrace serious benchmarking against the economic miracles delivered by our neighbors, we will be left reinventing the wheel and throwing decades upon decades of progress.

In other words, the Asian Tigers demonstrated to the world that rapid economic development cum nation-building is a reality, not a pipedream.

What do we keep missing? We’re stuck with addressing jobs, poverty, and inclusion and pursuing quantitative tools but no forward, lateral, and creative thinking.

We have no experience designing and assembling the requisite “ecosystem” to equip us to navigate the journey from poverty to prosperity. Moreover, as we take our caste system for granted, we won’t slay the dragon of political patronage and oligarchy.

Let’s hold it right there. 

I am exercising academic freedom — an element of freedom, democracy, and the free market that I chose to represent in Eastern Europe — when I contrast the “academic” from the real world.

Consider these two examples: Those familiar with the blog may recall how I assisted a Ph.D. candidate in her dissertation. “I will only help you if you commit to addressing a real-world challenge.” And she did and employed her dissertation to manage the brand she worked for, elevating her to global marketing director.

And much earlier, when a South Korean group attended an innovation and global competitiveness course at an Ivy, I hosted them at my former Fortune 500 company. The lead professor was a friend, and with the opening of the former Soviet bloc, he organized a program in Prague and invited a group of us from corporate America to give them a crash course on innovation and global competitiveness.

What about the morality of modern economics, as raised by Elfren Cruz? “In her book “Thinking Like an Economist,” University of Michigan sociologist Elizabeth P. Bergman wrote that it was not until the 1960s that the discipline of economics began to have a serious role in policy making. From then through the mid-1980s, government agencies established economic and policy offices. These offices began shaping major policy decisions using such techniques as cost-effectiveness analysis, which searches for the cheapest way to achieve a goal, and cost-benefit analysis, which asks whether the goal is worth pursuing in the first place. These events have made economics much more prestigious and influential than history, sociology, and other disciplines. There was focus on the end goal rather than the process.”

Recall that the blog often speaks to the elements of cognitive development. The challenge of nation-building is beyond binary thinking and extends to “multiplicity” and relativism – or the imperative of context.

Unsurprisingly, neuroscience has influenced behavioral economics and distinguishes it from classical economics.

What do we keep missing? We’re stuck with addressing jobs, poverty, and inclusion and pursuing quantitative tools but no forward, lateral, and creative thinking.

It’s worth repeating: Vietnam overtook the Philippines’ GDP per capita in 2020. Moreover, they put poverty in the rearview mirror. How? By taking the playbook of the once Asian Tigers, “beg for foreign money and technology.”

Here’s an analogy to explain why Juan de la Cruz remains in binary thinking.

Look at how we drive our cars or motorbikes. Courtesy driving or defensive driving is not in our psyche. Because to get from point A to point B on our roads, we must be in “survival mode.” The wife would constantly remember that motorists keep the outer or emergency lane open in America. In the Philippines, we would take whatever space we find. Unsurprisingly, gridlock is the rule on Philippine roads, not the exception.

We don’t trust the system because ours is a dysfunctional one.

Think of our crab mentality. For example, we won’t prioritize and leverage Pareto because we are in survival mode.

“The Philippines ranks as the 15th most unequal of 63 countries. More than half of laborers with only elementary schooling or less are in agriculture. Household heads who are college graduates have an average per capita income fourfold higher than household heads with no more than elementary education.” [“Poverty and inequality in the Philippines,” Ernesto M. Pernia, The Philippine Daily Inquirer, 2nd Dec 2022.]

Nation-building “is no longer just economics. We must open our eyes and focus on a bigger canvas, not just economic indicators. Still, most social, political, and other inequality indicators frustrate our efforts to build social cohesion and unite people around certain reforms.” [“PHL urged to focus economic policy on keeping middle class prosperous,” BusinessWorld, 24th Nov 2022]

Of course, we have world-class businesses and entrepreneurs, yet we can’t ignore that ours is a dysfunctional system.

“JFC'S founder, chair, and “chief taste officer” (CTO), Dr. Tony Tan Caktiong, ranks among the genuinely world-class entrepreneurs in the likes of Jack Ma of China and Jeff Bezos of the United States.

“A FEW MONTHS AGO, TAN CAKTIONG WAS CHOSEN AS THE SOLE AWARDEE of the “RVR Award for Nation Building” by its sponsors: the Phinma Corp., the Asian Institute of Management (AIM), and the Manila Jaycees.” [“World-class Filipino enterprise,” Artemio V. Panganiban, WITH DUE RESPECT, Philippine Daily Inquirer, 2nd Jan 2023]

What do we keep missing? We’re stuck with addressing jobs, poverty, and inclusion and pursuing quantitative tools but no forward, lateral, and creative thinking.

We have no experience designing and assembling the requisite “ecosystem” to equip us to navigate the journey from poverty to prosperity. Moreover, as we take for granted our caste system, we won’t slay the dragon of political patronage and oligarchy.

What to do?

Let’s quote from an earlier posting: “Ramon Ang’s Bulacan initiative, beyond the Bulacan airport, must mirror the Pearl River Delta Economic Zone ecosystem and generate “incremental” exports of $200 billion. That will pave the way for the Philippines to match the export revenues of our neighbors. And which is how Vietnam eliminated poverty.

“As the blog has raised, the BOI must be in the crosshairs to assume this challenge and toss our historical models in crafting investment incentives. 

“And recall, the blog challenged the Philippine president to invite the most prominent investors, especially in technology like TMCC, Samsung, and Apple, personally and pick their brains on how the Philippines can match if not outdo the neighbors' efforts. Mahathir did this by creating a tech advisory group that included Bill Gates.

“And last November, Zelensky of Ukraine signed an investment partnership with the CEO of BlackRock CEO Larry Fink. BlackRock is the world’s largest asset manager.”

Let’s hold it right there.

We have over 400 export processing zones under the PEZA. Yet, we generate the most negligible export revenues. How many more export processing zones are we contemplating, given the NEDA 5-year development plan?

Sadly, we can’t wrap our heads around Pareto and distinguish the “vital few” from the “trivial many.”

Is the Philippine economy half-full or half-empty?

What are we glossing over in the upbeat tenor of NEDA? For example, Vietnam overtook the Philippines’ GDP per capita in 2020. Moreover, they put poverty in the rearview mirror. How? By taking the playbook of the once Asian Tigers, “beg for foreign money and technology.”

Yet, we are still forging along the same path reliant on the OFW remittances and call centers, including the 6.0 to 7.0 percent growth metric.

In other words, we’re stuck in logical yet linear and incremental thinking. And that is despite decades of underperformance as an economy.

Gising bayan!