Sunday, February 12, 2023

The challenge is to be “dynamic” and “principled.”

If Juan de la Cruz is to move from “know it all” to “learn it all,” he must embrace dynamism yet be principled.

But is that too high a mountain to climb?

Consider: We are parochial and insular. We value hierarchy and paternalism and rely on political patronage and oligarchy; ours is a culture of impunity.

“The Philippines ranks 116th out of 180 countries in the global corruption index. Transparency International included the Philippines again in the list of countries identified as “significant decliners” in Asia-Pacific, with its score dropping five points from 38—the country’s highest—in 2014 when it ranked 85th out of 175.

“What that means is that our country is among the most corrupt in the world, not that we have posted a significant decline in corrupt activities in our bureaucracy.” [“No significant decline in corruption levels,” Ernesto M. Hilario, About Town, manilastandard.net, 3rd Feb 2023]

In other words, we will attract not the desirable FDIs and technology but harmful foreign elements. Think “mafia” types living next door. Then think how we, in the Philippine elite and chattering classes, would turn a blind eye to EJKs. God bless our souls. God bless this country.

On the other hand, the private sector, represented by MAP, continues to do its thing. Being from the private sector, I am elated.

“In the Edelman Trust Barometer today, “business” is the most trusted element in society. The reason is that people have given up on politicians who seem to be out for themselves and gridlocked. Most top-ranking politicians are in their 70s and 80s and unfamiliar with what people need. I think people are looking to businesses to help solve problems like climate change, healthcare, income inequality, food shortages, and supply chain.

“Government is not set up to deal with those things. They can pass laws but can’t address them, so everyone’s looking to business. That’s the challenge for today’s leaders: if they don’t address today’s problems, they won’t be good leaders, I can tell you.” [“Author Talks: Bill George sets a course for ‘true north,’” McKinsey, 15th Sep 2022; George is Harvard professor and former Medtronic CEO]

“MAP today has solidified its standing as a professional, impartial, and independent organization whose advocacies extend beyond its mission to achieve management excellence.

“We initiate, support and reinforce in multiple platforms to influence changes for the better. During its strategic meeting, we committed to working on crafting and implementing a two-pronged strategy to significantly contribute to this objective: by (a) bridging and enhancing the internal fundamentals and (b) harnessing our collective strengths to help in building a national future in shared prosperity.

“Our 2023 theme is “Bridging and Building a Progressive Future.” That will guide our directions and activities for the year. We mapped out six priority programs aptly embodied in the acronym B R I D G E: (1) We keep Bridging our internal strengths; (2) Focus on Resilience and recovery; (3) Initiate and welcome Innovation; (4) Advocate Diversity, equity, and inclusion; (5) Make a strong push for Growth and people development; (6) Base our actions on what can contribute to the environment, social and governance goals.

“These priority programs integrate the significant concerns of our members gathered from the responses in a quick survey in November. The results identified the Top 10 issues ranked according to priority. We duly noted that (1) ease of doing business remains to be the top concern, followed by (2) economy, (3) energy, (4) climate change, (5) competitiveness of local industries, (6) education, (7) agriculture, (8) infrastructure, (9) environment, social and governance goals and (10) dealing with local governments.

“Ciel Habito, the former secretary of NEDA under the Ramos administration, heads the Cluster on Resilience and Recovery. His group will persistently pursue the eight-point MAP recommendations that MAP submitted in 2022 to the then-incoming administration.

"To provide inputs to our members on the business horizon, we will hold an economic briefing. We feel that we can enrich the context of economic prospects if we can identify investment opportunities we can take advantage of to expand our markets.

“This year, therefore, we will introduce an innovation of twinning the briefing on the economy with an investment campaign scheduled within the first quarter of the year. The pursuit of this initiative is in partnership with the Department of Trade and Industry.”

Recall that my former Fortune 500 company chose me to be the regional manager over my Asian peers because we Filipinos were more sophisticated in business and industry than our neighbors. Recall, too, that I was indolent as a student. But I have been exposed to modern business in the Philippines through five different sectors.

Sadly, we didn’t demonstrate their dynamism. Yet they’re not perfect.

The challenge is to be “dynamic” yet “principled.”

Let’s hold it right there.

Recall that the blog never tires of speaking to humankind being a subset set of this universe in constant motion and expansion.

The blog asserts that democracy is the mirror image of Christianity, i.e., the imperative of personal responsibility to pursue the common good translates to “love of neighbor.”

Yet, we don’t have to reinvent the wheel because we witness the photosynthesis phenomenon 24/7, i.e., interdependence is the law of nature.

Humankind is about thriving in this world. Juan de la Cruz is beyond survival.

In other words, we must overcome the shortsightedness that defines Juan de la Cruz. And the mantra of “inclusion” is a classic example. It is insane. Yet, it is logical, given our caste system.

The bottom line: Our neighbors turned us from the basket case of Asia and then the perennial laggard – because we did not demonstrate their dynamism.

But do we see the door opened for us? Our neighbors aren’t perfect. But we must demonstrate dynamism to get through this open door.

How do we translate that in the “real world”?

Here’s a quote from an earlier posting: I dipped my toes in the “call center” industry per my promise to a friend (who runs an enterprise.)

At the end of a two-day business review, I shared my impressions, “Be close to the trees, but don’t miss the forest.” Long story short, I challenged the team to “double the business.” Several weeks ago, I shared with them a GPS model – to guide them in their planning session: Where are you; Where do you want to be; How will you get there?

I had asked for the character of the nut that the team had to crack, especially the target market and its size and the best-in-class competition – the superiority they demonstrate, from the product architecture to the length and breadth of the customer experience.

Philippine enterprises – like our economy – are still minuscule. The only way for them to thrive globally is to scale up.

Yet, scaling up is not in our lexicon. And it comes from our caste system where [the concept of] “scale” is beyond Juan de la Cruz and is the privilege of the hierarchy – as in an oligarchy. 

Our worldview is between “privilege and entitlement.”

Consider: BOI reported adopting the Pareto principle to focus on “big ticket” items. That was after Mr. Ramon Ang shared his Bulacan initiative, which would generate $200 billion in export revenues beyond the Bulacan airport — and negate the advantage of our neighbors. And as the blog raised, we can include agribusiness under the Bulacan umbrella.

We cannot hold to the sacredness of the 6%-7% GDP growth metric if we want to be ahead of the curve in energy development, being imperative in leapfrogging industrialization, for example.

That’s why the blog never tires of distinguishing (a) logical yet linear and incremental thinking and (b) forward, lateral and creative thinking. 

And that is why the Ang initiative must be a driving force in our journey from poverty to prosperity, as well as the shift in the BOI direction. And note that I challenged my BPO friends to double their business.

What we must learn and want to claim is dynamism. We don’t want the world to keep leaving us behind.

Said differently, we must pursue the sectors of the economy, be it agriculture, manufacturing, or service, knowing full well that whatever industry we focus on must generate the equivalent of the vital few. And that means we deliver against the metrics of innovation and global competitiveness.

The challenge is to be “dynamic” yet “principled.”

“The traditional model of the leader-hero who saves the day knows it all, is the most intelligent person in the room, and is too often driven by power, fame, glory, or money is not appropriate in today’s environment. That is true for several reasons: Today’s fast-changing, complex, and unpredictable environment necessitates a different kind of leadership. Nobody can claim to have all the answers to solve the complex crises we’re facing, and the most adaptable organizations are those in which decisions are decentralized.

“With the idea that a company’s purpose is far more than making money and gaining ground, the hard-charging, profit-optimizing hero-leader model has lost much of its appeal.

“An increasing number of employees now value authenticity and connection over a facade of strength and infallibility. The nature of work has changed from the more mechanical, repetitive type to jobs that require ingenuity and creativity.

“Successful hero-leaders can easily start believing that they’re untouchable and, ultimately, indispensable. It’s easy to be seduced by power, fame, glory, and money. It’s easy to become disconnected from reality and colleagues, surrounded by sycophants and “yay-sayers.”

“Unsurprisingly, people today expect a different kind of leader.” [“5 Principles of Purposeful Leadership,” Hubert Joly, Harvard Business Review, 6th Apr 2022]

“Rightly or wrongly, ‘ethics’ often has a connotation of right and wrong. ‘Values’ tend to be idiosyncratic to individuals and organizations. Values can and should differ among organizations, and there is no right and wrong, per se. ‘Principles’ are more actionable rules of conduct that inform decisions, and those principles are particular to a person or a company.

“Principles are tradeable currency. We can write them down, debate, prioritize, dismiss, or adopt them. By clearly articulating a principle — “It's always wrong to lie to customers” or “Social media companies are responsible for all their users’ content” — it’s easier to step back and look at the idea objectively. Where might the “principle” help guide a decision? Are there situations where that principle is less important than a conflicting principle, or do principles need to evolve?

“None of this is to say that the terms “ethics” and “values” must be out of discussions of entrepreneurship, but rather that the concept of “principles” can give students a tool to approach complex decisions without presupposing a universally correct answer or ethical system.” [“Teaching Principled Entrepreneurship,” Luke Sykora, Stanford University, 23rd Oct 2019; https://ecorner.stanford.edu/articles/teaching-principled-entrepreneurship/]

Those familiar with the blog may recall that when my wife and I arrived in Eastern Europe, I anchored their introduction to the free world: Freedom, democracy, and the free market are not about rules but principles.

Yet, the above articles would still speak to the American experiment – because “principles are tradeable currency.”

Recall the 41 men on the Mayflower that left the Old World for the New World. Despite the instincts for everyone to be for themselves, man, woman, and family, this group of men realized why they sought the New World in the first place. And so they committed to pursuing the common good via self-government, which presupposes personal responsibility.

And they became the model of freedom and democracy despite the countless times they tripped themselves. And they again stumbled; fast-forward to the present.

Why? The pursuit of the common good is not about being conservative or progressive. The latter are values, not principles per se. See above; principles are tradeable currency, while values presuppose a universally correct answer or ethical system.

Conflicting principles, on the other hand, need to evolve. It’s what dynamism is because “reality” is beyond any human experience or system, to paraphrase the late George Gorospe, SJ.

It applies to the principle of interdependence being the law of nature. And why freedom-loving people and nations commit to pursuing the common good. It is what humankind learned after two great wars to prevent the third. It is not a claim of perfection, thus not the choice between evils, but the personal responsibility to seek the common good.

If Filipinos struggle to figure that out, we should not feel inadequate. Even Americans are in awe of the commitment of the Ukrainians to freedom and democracy.

The challenge is to be “dynamic” yet “principled.”

Recall that the blog never tires of speaking to humankind being a subset set of this universe in constant motion and expansion. Do the elements of cognitive development come to mind? Beyond binary thinking, there is multiplicity and relativism – the imperative of context.

Maharlika is just one of the zillion times we tripped ourselves. Why? We take context for granted.

Yet, we don’t have to reinvent the wheel. We don’t want to envy Singapore or Norway. We want to be a first-world economy and nation.

One more time with feeling. We want to be a first-world economy and nation.

That is the “context,” not Maharlika. When we have internalized the context, we can think laterally and creatively to figure out many ways to get there. But we must prioritize and then connect the dots into an ecosystem.

If we are to reinvent Juan de la Cruz, how do we relate that fundamental given to the home, the school, the community, or the church? For example, the late George Gorospe (SJ) lamented that we could teach the young about “reality” – that it is beyond any human experience or system – yet as a people, we won’t internalize it given the home, the work setting, and the “community-at-large” live by our instincts, our caste system. 

We are parochial and insular. We value hierarchy and paternalism and rely on political patronage and oligarchy; ours is a culture of impunity.

How do we overcome our instincts? Should we start with reinventing Philippine education? As a freshman, I remember the introduction to the modern math concept of sets and subsets in Math 101. 

But how should we pull together the fundamental givens as a bridge between the academic and the “real world”?

“Tito, we learned how to be entrepreneurs in the school and then exposed to the real world, including overseas.”

A nephew and two friends attended Enderun Colleges and found themselves overseas because the school curriculum included stints with the world’s greatest chefs. Today their restaurant has been featured by Tatler a couple of times, being among the top dining places in the country.

“I know it is difficult to look far ahead, but having a small flowchart in your head would be nice. As someone who owns a restaurant braving the pandemic, don’t only focus on cooking or what happens in the kitchen. There’s more to it than that. 

“Be logical with your decisions, and if you can manage the risks of your choices, then do it. You are not alone – you have a team, and you work with that team together as a family. You have a sea of responsibilities; let your team help you navigate. They have your back, and you’ve got theirs. Don’t be a superstar.” [Running A Restaurant During The Pandemic: Alphonse Sotero Of Lampara Speaks Out | Tatler Asia]

Recall the Vietnam Food Association. That is how they cut the many layers in their agribusiness industry. For example, farmers voluntarily join the association and do not need intermediaries. 

Question: If UP Los BaƱos will lead the reinvention of Philippine agriculture, should we adopt the Enderun model so that students learn how to blaze the trails for our farmers?

What about UP Engineering? Should they learn why the EPZA export zones model is not the way to go to be globally competitive? Should they have stints overseas to learn from the Asian Tigers, for example? 

How do our engineers learn and internalize the reality of Pareto? What about our economists?

How do we overcome our instincts? How do we reinvent Philippine education? 

We must be close to the trees but not miss the forest. 

We must be great analysts but must master analytics. It is about forward, lateral and creative thinking.

If innovation is beyond R&D, and nation-building beyond Economics, we must now pull neuroscience into our journey from poverty to prosperity. 

“Twelve Researchers Recognized At Philippines Promising Star Awards 2016 - Asian Scientist Magazine.” “The Philippines Promising Star Awards 2016 recognizes researchers of Filipino nationality based in the Philippines who have produced world-class research papers in their respective fields as indexed in the Web of Science Core Collection.

“The recipients represent nine broad fields spanning social science, computer science, clinical medicine, plant & animal science, neuroscience & behavior, economics & business, molecular biology & genetics, materials science and environment/ecology.”

These Filipino scientists’ challenge is adding value to our nation-building efforts. In other words, we can’t be too close to the trees that we miss the forest.

Consider: “Currently, PEZA oversees 421 ecozones hosting 4,346 locators. The ecozones have generated a total of 1.8 million direct jobs. PEZA is confident it will achieve its 10% investment growth target for 2023.” [“PEZA sets launch target of 1-3 ecozones a year,” BusinessWorld, 9th Feb 2023] 

In other words, because of the sacredness of the 6%-7% GDP growth metric, we are proud to see investment grow by 10%. 

“Scaling up” is not in our lexicon – because we mistake the academic world for the “real world.” And we can’t shake off the crab mentality.

The challenge is to be “dynamic” yet “principled.”

If Juan de la Cruz is to move from “know it all” to “learn it all,” he must embrace dynamism yet be principled.

But is that too high a mountain to climb?

Humankind is about thriving in this world. 

Juan de la Cruz is beyond survival.

Gising bayan! 

Monday, February 6, 2023

Be close to the trees, but don’t miss the forest.

This posting will confirm [and build on an earlier one] that I dipped my toes in the “call center” industry per my promise to a friend (who runs an enterprise.)

At the end of a two-day business review, I shared my impressions, “Be close to the trees, but don’t miss the forest.” Long story short, I challenged the team to “double the business.” Several weeks ago, I shared with them a GPS model – to guide them in their planning session: Where are you; Where do you want to be; How will you get there?

I had asked for the character of the nut that the team had to crack, especially the target market and its size and the best-in-class competition – the superiority they demonstrate, from the product architecture to the length and breadth of the customer experience.

Present in the review was an American, their representative in the US, who shared with the Filipino crew the fine-grained realities of the business on the ground. He did his homework.

For example, 84% of outsourcing deals come from the United States. That 66% of US companies with 50 or more employees outsource, against 29% of those with less than 50. And Deloitte anticipates the BPO sector to reach $212 billion in 2023, a 19% increase over 2019.

Because 71% of Americans think outsourcing harms the US economy, it is not surprising that there are 287,938 BPO service businesses in the US as of 2023, an increase of 3.7% from 2022. 60% of organizations turn to outsource for app development. [That is something the industry must keep an eye on and gear themselves to satisfy.]

Small businesses that can’t afford US-based providers seek “strong problem-solving skills” in choosing an outsourced team overseas. [In other words, there is more to BPO than answering calls.] Noteworthy, India is the most attractive country for outsourcing business services; the Philippines ranks in the top 10. [Still, despite its dominance in the IT-BPO industry, India must pursue manufacturing given its population size that is several folds that of Ireland and Israel, the two most prominent IT-BPO players after India, and consequently its alarming poverty rate. Manufacturing’s multiplier effect on the economy is more significant than the service industry because of the sub-industries it spawns. Unsurprisingly, India welcomes Apple’s plans to transfer 25% of its iPhone production from China to India.]

The average salary for a Filipino software developer is just $7,174, or 10% of the average American software developer. On the other hand, over 1 Million outsourced jobs are in danger due to automation. [That is something that Philippine BPOs must overcome by being proactive, moving up the value chain, and designing their product architecture accordingly.]

The bottom line for the Philippines: 8% of the Philippines’ GDP comes from BPO.

Question: Do I think my BPO friends can double their revenues, and why have I challenged them? I do; the team with the American representative agreed, and that is how they crafted their plans. For example, which clients present the most significant potential, and what product portfolio must they develop, recognizing that innovation and global competitiveness are the metrics?

Let’s hold it right there.

Since 84% of outsourcing comes from the US, they must be the focus. And note that their projected aggregate revenues would increase by 19% from 2019 to 2023. How come I challenged my friends to raise their sales projections by a hundred percent? Because the growth in the US – and over $21 trillion economy – outsourcing reflects the expansion of its GDP, i.e., a 6% growth is on the high side.

But Philippine enterprises – like our economy – are still minuscule. The only way for them to thrive globally is to scale up.

Yet, scaling up is not in our lexicon. And it comes from our caste system where [the concept of] “scale” is beyond Juan de la Cruz and is the privilege of the hierarchy – as in an oligarchy. See below; our worldview is between “privilege and entitlement.”

Andrew Masigan wrote, “As of mid-2022, the Philippine IT-BPO industry employed 1.43 million Filipinos and generated $29.1 billion in revenues. Compare this against the trifecta of knowledge superpowers – India, Ireland, and Israel, who realized $194 billion, $69 billion, and $44 billion in revenues in 2021, respectively.”

In other words, if we double Philippine BPO revenues, we will be up to roughly $60 billion. And we will be celebrating because of our sacred 6%-7% GDP growth metric. And Philippine enterprises, including the BPO industry, are tapping into that mindset. In other words, enough of the orthodoxy. Our economic managers, legislators, and think tanks must toss that mindset.

Why? We are no different from Laos, which delivered the exact numbers — 6%-7% GDP growth — over a decade, and we are still in the cellar.

Enter Mr. Ramon Ang and the BOI. They represent a new driving force — to scale up the Philippine economy — which we haven’t had for a longest time. And our job is to exploit it consistent with the force field theory in managing change — which is familiar to blog readers. As necessary is, to address the restraining forces expounded in this posting and by the blog for the last 14 years.

Here’s a quote from an earlier posting: Consider: BOI reported adopting the Pareto principle to focus on “big ticket” items. That was after Mr. Ramon Ang shared his Bulacan initiative, which would generate $200 billion in export revenues beyond the Bulacan airport — and negate the advantage of our neighbors. And as the blog raised, we can include agribusiness under the Bulacan umbrella.

Those are multifaceted challenges. And recall the elements of cognitive development. Beyond binary thinking, there is multiplicity and relativism — the imperative of context.

The bottom line: How do we pull them all together? Beyond the restrictive economic provisions of the Constitution, we have countless sets and subsets to align and harmonize. And it goes back to overcoming binary thinking. 

Consider: $200 billion in export revenues would be over 50% of the Philippine GDP. In other words, raising GDP by 50% will require a significant increase in energy needs. But because of economies of scale, we should be able to invest in power generation, for example.

Let’s hold it right there. 

We cannot hold to the sacredness of the 6%-7% GDP growth metric if we want to be ahead of the curve in energy development. That’s why the blog never tires of distinguishing (a) logical yet linear and incremental thinking and (b) forward, lateral and creative thinking. And that is why the Ang initiative must be a driving force in our journey from poverty to prosperity, as well as the shift in the BOI direction. And note that I challenged my BPO friends to double their business.

Can we toss Pinoy hubris?

Here’s a news item from BusinessWorld, 26th Jan 2023, “ECCP President Lars Wittig said that the group is expecting “billions of dollars” worth of foreign direct investment into industries like renewable energy (RE). The ECCP said the investment would come because of the Department of Energy’s green light to relax foreign ownership caps in RE, as outlined in Department Circular No. 2022-11-0034, as well as the amendments to the Foreign Investment Act, Retail Trade Liberalization Act, and Public Service Act.”

What is the context if we are to craft a robust economy? We must move beyond binary thinking, exploit multiplicity, and become a first-world economy. That is where we want to be.

For example, we cannot claim excellence in human resources because we speak English, and the service industry drives our economy. UP and Ateneo, our two top schools, have been left in the dust by their counterparts in the region. That we have a young population doesn’t give us a leg up. The demographic plus we think we own is a fallacy, given the staggering levels of poverty and hunger. What we must learn and claim is dynamism. We don’t want the world to keep leaving us behind.

Said differently, we must pursue the sectors of the economy, be it agriculture, manufacturing, or service, knowing full well that whatever industry we focus on must generate the equivalent of the vital few. And that means we deliver against the metrics of innovation and global competitiveness. We don’t have to be the “manufacturing hub” of the world. But we want to be a first-world economy.

That is how we must prioritize the industries and businesses that can deliver export revenues of $200 billion. For example, we can double the BPO revenues to $60 billion. In agriculture, we must teach our farmers the pursuit of the “common good” and replicate the Vietnam Food Association. In manufacturing, we must toss the current PEZA export zones model that reveals our crab mentality. We must craft investment incentives to mirror our neighbors’ efforts. Pareto. Pareto. Pareto.

It takes a village, and the Philippine elite and chattering classes could be the nucleus to lead this multifaceted challenge.

But then, can the economic managers, legislators, and think tanks update their respective portfolios and show the way?”

The good news is that the BOI appears to have shifted directions. From toiling figuring out the scores of industry road maps that never flew off the ground, they are now looking at “big ticket” items. And that is why the blog never tires of speaking to Samsung Vietnam.

Sadly, we can’t overcome binary thinking. We celebrated the OFW phenomenon because we assumed we couldn’t be in manufacturing. In the meantime, our neighbors, one after the other, had the opposite perspective and, one by one became Asian Tiger. 

Why? They are way beyond binary thinking and into multiplicity and relativism, which they translated as “begging for Western money and technology.”

But we’re still stuck at logical yet linear and incremental thinking. We don’t have this, and we don’t have that. We have corruption. We have no infrastructure.

Said differently, dynamism is not in our DNA. And it comes from our worldview between “privilege and entitlement.” 

Consider: We are parochial and insular. We value hierarchy and paternalism and rely on political patronage and oligarchy; ours is a culture of impunity.

Unsurprisingly, we cannot internalize that we are a subset of this dynamic universe in constant motion and expansion.

I was a regional manager at my old Fortune 500 company when these neighbors were doing their thing. They stepped up infrastructure initiatives and tapped Western money and technology to leapfrog industrialization.

Yet I was chosen as regional manager over my Asian peers because we Filipinos were more sophisticated in business and industry than our neighbors. Recall that I was indolent as a student. But I have been exposed to modern business in the Philippines through five different sectors.

Sadly, we didn’t demonstrate their dynamism. But they’re not perfect. 

Here’s a 23rd Jan article in The Economist about Vietnam: “With stricter accounting, corrupt officials have no interest in implementing capital-investment projects because they can’t “eat” from them. Even some honest officials are so scandal-averse that they won’t approve projects. The effect shows up in investment statistics.

“The disbursement rate of state capital investment—the share of the government’s planned spending on roads and the like —fell from around 70% in 2011-14 to about 50% in 2019. After a post-covid jump, last year it dropped to 58%.

“Officials are afraid of any responsibility, giving signatures or preparing public documents for projects. The resultant snarl-up is evident even in tax collection. Several foreign residents report being unable to pay their taxes. The relevant officials worried that they might be held responsible for collecting the wrong amount.

“The logjam is slowing desperately needed infrastructure projects. The nationwide North-South Expressway remains a patchwork. Ho Chi Minh City’s promised metro has yet to open a decade after work on it began. That will not jeopardize Vietnam’s growth in the short term. It was estimated at 7.5% in 2022 and to top 6% this year.”

But then, Vietnam has its pluses. “Vietnam is liberalizing its economy to welcome foreign industry. In 2015 the government opened 50 industries to foreign competition and slashed regulation in hundreds more. Last year, it sold a majority stake in the biggest state-owned brewer, Sabeco, to a foreign firm. Vietnam's enthusiasm for free-trade deals has made it especially alluring to foreign investors. It is a founding member of the “Trans-Pacific Partnership,” a multilateral trade agreement that includes Australia, Canada, and Japan. It is due to sign a trade pact with the European Union soon. The deal signed with South Korea in 2015 has made it South Korea’s fourth-biggest trading partner.” [“Why Samsung of South Korea is the biggest firm in Vietnam,” The Economist, 12th Apr 2018]

Be close to the trees but don’t miss the forest.

How? We must very quickly overcome Pinoy hubris. We don’t know it all. We must learn it all, say, from our neighbors. Take dynamism. We are the laughingstock of the region. Hubris can’t be in our consciousness.

Gising bayan! 

Monday, January 30, 2023

Of ideology, the academic, and the “real world.”

Scanning our media scene, do we recognize the elements of ideology, the academic, or the real world?

Consider these two articles: (a) Think tank urges more focus on domestic industry, agri; skeptical about FDI impact and (b) Liberalize agriculture to allow crucial imports – NEDA chief.

Since Vietnam is the latest neighbor to overtake us, here are two exciting agriculture-related pieces: (a) Rice production in Vietnam and (b) Vietnam Food Association Charter.

Rice production in Vietnam.

“Rice growing in Mekong Delta has an ancient history traced to the Khmer regime of the 18th century. It was taken over by the Vietnamese. However, the Cambodians still consider this area “Kampuchea Krom or Lower Cambodia,” unable to forget that they owned this area in the past. Cambodia even attacked Vietnam in 1978 to take control of the Mekong Delta. But the latter defeated them decisively. This delta was the last part of present-day Vietnam annexed from Cambodia.

“Its present status under the Vietnamese is, however, a large swathe of green carpet of rice paddy. This development dates back to the French, who colonized Vietnam in the middle of the 19th century with the primary objective of exporting rice grown in the delta to meet the enormous costs of colonization. They developed a maze of the canal system in the delta to grow three rice crops in a year.

“During World War II, when the Japanese occupied Vietnam and exploited the rich delta by exporting rice to their country, it denied nearly several million Vietnamese of their essential staple.

“At the end of the Vietnamese war in 1975, the country faced acute hardships. Communist Party members of the national party were at a low rung and entrusted with managerial responsibility for developing the Mekong delta in South Vietnam. And the Communist regime established cooperative farming through communes.

“The government also supplied the farmers with seed, fertilizer, and other essentials. As this helped the poor farmers, it was popularly called “the iron rice bowl” – this allegory was to convey that “no one would get rich by this system, there was a promise that every person would be cared for by the government; a system where no one would fall through the cracks.”

“Thus, all the rice-growing delta fields became the state property. People wanting to buy and carry rice from the delta got 80 kilograms allocation, subject to strict monitoring at police check posts. Devastating floods and insect infestation of large fields further aggravated this condition.

“Realizing the folly of State Control, the Government of Vietnam, in 1986, allowed the farmers “to grow and sell their rice.” Sure enough, farmers received incentives to grow rice in the delta, and Vietnam became one of the leading exporters of rice. Then came the Wetland Development initiative, including the most significant Land Law (1994) that gave rights to the farmers and accelerated growth of the Mekong Delta and increased income to the people.” [Wikipedia]

Vietnam Food Association Charter.

“It is a social and occupational organization of Vietnam enterprises from all economic sectors operating in the field of production, processing, and trading food, agricultural products, and other products processed from food; voluntarily joining together to establish the Association to co-ordinate food trading activities to ensure business efficiency for the protection of legitimate interests of its members.

“The Association shall contribute to boosting production development, building material, and technical facilities for the improvement  of product quality and business efficiency of the food commodity industry and ensuring food security in compliance with the policies of the State.” [ABOUT US - Vietnam Food Association (vietfood.org.vn)]

Do we see how Vietnamese farmers understand the “common good”? Said differently, they don’t suffer from the crab mentality.

Should we stop and ponder?

Can we expect Juan de la Cruz to embrace the common good and toss the values of hierarchy and paternalism? And develop a hardy mindset – to hold dearly the challenge we face and commit to overcoming them while recognizing that we have no control over others and that the onus to change is on us.

Do we see that colonization was not all bad for the Vietnamese? The French developed a maze of the canal system in the delta to grow three rice crops in a year. Then think of the OFW phenomenon – today a significant leg of the Philippine economy – and the Filipino facility for the English language courtesy of the [medium of instruction left by the] Americans.

Here’s a quote from an earlier posting: “Recall how often the blog raised the Pearl River Delta Economic Zone ecosystem (in Guangdong, China) as the best practice model to attract foreign money and technology. And all that Vietnam did was replicate the China experience and find a partner in Samsung.

“Why does the blog keep distinguishing “analysis” and “analytics”? Please recall the article, “The 50-year ‘disease’ in Philippine agriculture.” Yet, from rice tariffication, and we now want to do the rest of the agri products to address shortages. That is how “analysis” looks. On the other hand, the Vietnamese learned “analytics” from the Asian Tigers, which they translated to “ecosystem.” Consider: The operations of Samsung entail a vast ecosystem. And not to forget that Vietnam is a top rice exporter like Thailand. The agri ecosystem of both countries is something we want to learn. It is beyond liberalizing the agriculture sector.”

Liberalizing the agriculture sector is not why Vietnam is a significant rice exporter. Instead, they live by the imperative of an ecosystem, and the Vietnam Food Association is an excellent example. Can we Filipinos toss the crab mentality?

What else has Vietnam exploited to be a world-class rice producer? And this should make us Filipinos cry because we should have been the first to benefit from rice R&D. 

If our economic managers are listening, tariffication is too technocratic yet won’t make the Philippines a world-class rice producer like Vietnam. 

Between being academic and ideological would instead consign us to the cellar. 

On the other hand, Vietnam has exploited IRRI. “The International Rice Research Institute (IRRI), headquartered in the Philippines, has significantly enhanced the knowledge base of rice farming in Vietnam. Their research efforts have continually aimed to grow rice faster with higher yields. That has boosted the confidence level of Vietnamese scientists who hope their country will one day be the rice producer to feed the world. The IRRI has trained and worked with Vietnamese scientists since 1970. The scientists trained by IRRI now hold key positions in rice research institutions, universities, and government organizations.”

But let’s go back to the think tank urging us to focus on domestic industry and agri, but skeptical about FDIs.

Here’s a quote from an earlier posting: “2017 was a year of great significance for both the Vietnamese economy and Samsung Vietnam. Vietnam’s export turnover for the first time in history reached more than 214 billion USD, and Samsung Vietnam’s export turnover also achieved a breakthrough with more than 54 billion USD for the first time.

“Samsung Vietnam contributes more than 25% to the total export turnover of Vietnam. This miraculous figure is 150 times higher than Samsung Vietnam’s total export turnover in 2009 ($350 million) when SEV began production.

“As of June 2018, Samsung has reached the milestone of 1 billion high-tech innovative products manufactured in Vietnam. The 1 billion products include smartphones, tablets, smartwatches, and other essential mobile phone products.

“The Samsung Bac Ninh factory produced more than 625 million products, and Samsung Thai Nguyen made more than 431 million. Vietnam is currently the second largest smartphone export in the world after China, and Samsung plays a significant role in this achievement.”

The bottom line: Vietnam overtook us in 2020 when their export revenues reached almost $260 billion against our close to $80 billion. Moreover, they put poverty in the rearview mirror.

But let’s hear the think tank: “More countries are closing than opening over the last decade because they are protecting their economies (from a possible recession).”

And given the rising far-right extremism, characterized by protectionism, IBON Foundation has all the right to be true to its ideology.

Those familiar with the blog know I chose (as a volunteer development worker) to represent freedom, democracy, and the free market in Eastern Europe. And while my former Fortune 500 company obtained a blue passport for me – given my role in the company with over 200 markets or countries – I opted not to exercise the right to vote.

Recall this quote from a recent posting: “Business” is the most trusted element in society. The reason is that people have given up on politicians who seem to be out for themselves and gridlocked. Most top-ranking politicians are in their 70s and 80s and unfamiliar with what people need.”

Recall, too, that as a practitioner and not an academic, I speak from real-world experiences. For example, the 21st-century demands “innovation and global competitiveness.” And that is not surprising because we are a subset of this universe in constant motion and expansion.

Countries cannot produce everything they need, i.e., interdependence is the law of nature. And like a broken record, the blog never fails to speak to the photosynthesis phenomenon.

But that is not an academic assertion. Let’s take a peek at the business of my Eastern European friends. 

And I mean a peek because I am doing this here in the Philippines, logging in to our intranet, which I do every day wherever I am. And I can see what is going on. But I don’t do analysis. I do analytics. Everyone in the company does “analysis,” but I keep them in dynamic mode.

As noted below, I am talking about how the prior year ended and how this year will play out. Why? To keep their eye on the future, what they are doing today, as was the prior year, must build on what they must be.

[But to Filipinos, we better keep an eye on Vietnam because they want to be the world’s top rice producer. And tariffication and ideology can’t be our response. And more fundamentally, we must know where we want to be. For example, we want to be a first-world economy and nation. That is what we want to figure out. And if we’re going to become such a wealthy nation, we don’t have to reinvent the wheel and be bogged down by ideological debates. All we need is to “learn it all” from our neighbors. We must overcome the “know it all” hubris. Consider: We are the laughingstock stock of the region; hubris can’t be in our consciousness.]

Firstly, my Eastern European friends were born and raised as socialists under Soviet rule. Yet, instead of the promised utopia, the Soviets left them the poorest European country. And hence the wife’s first reaction when we arrived was unsurprising, “What are we doing in this godforsaken place?”

They are into making and selling day-to-day consumer products, not high-technology devices, and I have assisted them for the last twenty years.

Question: Don’t day-to-day consumer products risk being shut out in the global market because locals can quickly produce them?

We Filipinos may feel that way, given that innovation and global competitiveness are foreign to us.

Can we accept that reality, or does national pride compel us to be in denial? But recall that our mantra is to cater to the bottom of the pyramid, given our values of hierarchy and paternalism, shooting ourselves in the foot, unable to run astride with our neighbors that begged for foreign money and technology and catapulted them to first-world economies and nations.

Consider the state of the business of these friends: They have 18 brands they market in several countries. Four represent 79% of the company: three regional and one global brand.

Last year’s total sales revenues rose 27%, and this year will be up 35%. The number two brand is the global brand which accounts for 17% of the business. In 2022, its revenues were up 40% from sales in 70 countries; this year, it will grow 47%.

Seven of the top ten markets are in Eastern Europe, and the balance is in the West: Germany, the US, and the UK.

Noteworthy is a fast-growing global brand. In 2022, its sales grew by 143%; this year, it will be up 195%.

But what is it about “innovation and global competitiveness” demanded by the 21st century?

It is understanding the human need – even for day-to-day consumer products – and figuring out the best-in-class metrics. It means employing forward, lateral, and creative thinking continually. In other words, the enterprise, consistent with the dynamism of this universe, must constantly be elevating the brand to attain the best-in-class metrics.

Still, adhering to Pareto and the imperative to prioritize is a must. And that is why among the 18 brands, the enterprise focuses on the top four and the next two most promising ones.

Question: How come these Eastern European friends who grew up behind the “iron curtain” confidently reach out to the rest of the world? Twenty years ago, they weren’t a profitable going concern, yet today are giant killers.

They’ve turned their back on the utopia promised by their Soviet masters and chose to pursue freedom, democracy confidently, and the free market — because they know the future is in their hands. It’s called a “hardy mindset,” familiar to those who read the blog.

Scanning our media scene, do we recognize the elements of ideology, the academic, or the real world?

Given that we are a subset set of this universe in constant motion and expansion, on the one hand, and on the other, ideology and the academic world, when they are static, may pull us away from the “real world.”

And that is why the blog has challenged our worldview over the last fourteen years.

Consider: Juan de la Cruz moved from the basket case of Asia to the perennial regional laggard. And between being ideological and academic could consign us to the cellar.

But then again, the Philippine caste system reinforces our values of hierarchy and paternalism, and they would explain why poverty and hunger have defined Juan de la Cruz.

Gising bayan! 

Thursday, January 26, 2023

From “know it all” to “learn it all.”

This posting will highlight a podcast by McKinsey & Company, “Author Talks: Bill George sets a course for “true north,” 15th Sep 2022, about his new book, True North: Leading Authentically in Today’s Workplace. George is a Harvard professor and former Medtronic CEO. [Here’s the link to the podcast: [https://www.mckinsey.com/featured-insights/mckinsey-on-books/author-talks-bill-george-sets-a-course-for-true-north?cid=app]]

“In the Edelman Trust Barometer today, business is the most trusted element in society. The reason is that people have given up on politicians who seem to be out for themselves and gridlocked. Most top-ranking politicians are in their 70s and 80s and unfamiliar with what people need. I think people are looking to businesses to help solve problems like climate change, healthcare, income inequality, food shortages, and supply chain.

“Government is not set up to deal with those things. They can pass laws but can’t address them, so everyone’s looking to business. That’s the challenge for today’s leaders: if they don’t address today’s problems, they won’t be good leaders, I can tell you.

“In my book, I feature whom I consider role models of the new way of leading, many of whom are baby boomers. They are the ones that emerging leaders seek.

“Let’s take Satya Nadella at Microsoft: he transformed that company. Mary Barra brought General Motors out of bankruptcy and is making it into a new company. Hubert Joly was very committed to “purpose” at Best Buy, and now his successor, Corie Barry, is doing a great job. These are the forerunner leaders. Those kinds of leaders influence the younger leaders who are coming along, which I also feature in the book. We need role models. We need quality role models. We don’t need people who are just out for themselves.”

Here’s a soundbite that stuck with me; how Nadella transformed Microsoft, “From know it all to learn it all.”

“Hunger” is an embarrassing subject. Whereas the Government now has monthly surveys on unemployment and underemployment and has promised to update its poverty figures every two years instead of every three, it has hardly any numbers on hunger.

“Econometric modeling of hunger at the UP School of Statistics (UPSS). Using the SWS quarterly data, [UPSS] researchers Dennis S. Mapa, Fatima C. Han, and Kristina Claire O. Estrada showed that an increase in food prices in one quarter would raise hunger for five subsequent quarters. In contrast, an increase in underemployment would raise it for two quarters (Hunger incidence in the Philippines: facts, determinants, and challenges,” paper for a forum of the National Academy of Science and Technology, 2/10/2010).

“I think the [UPSS] econometricians examined the gross domestic product and other potential determinants and found little correlation. I hope they will update their analysis with data after 2010, including the pandemic time. (Mapa has been head of the Philippine Statistics Authority since 2019, by the way).

“The lengthy hump in hunger was generally unnoticed by development analysts, perhaps because it did not affect the financial sector. It remains a perennial problem.” [“The perennial problem of hunger,” Mahar Mangahas, SOCIAL CLIMATE, Philippine Daily Inquirer, 21st Jan 2023.]

Then consider: “The 50-year ‘disease’ in Philippine agriculture,” Ramon L. Clarete, Introspective, BusinessWorld, 15th Jan 2023. “High food prices may be a fluke, as the farming sector goes through the ravages of extreme weather, losing productivity in the process. But this unfavorable situation has been with us through the years. Agriculture growth has gradually tanked in the past half a century, so much so that its record has become an insignificant statistic in the country’s gross domestic product accounting.”

Unsurprisingly, Juan de la Cruz went from the basket case of Asia to the perennial regional laggard.

“If there is one factor hindering the Philippines from catching up with its dynamic neighbors in the ASEAN, the outdated mindset has remained with us from the last century. ‘Customer orientation’ has long been the crux in business operations, and clearly understood that failure to internalize this culture will result in a loss to competition and eventually the replacement of the boss.” [The 21st-century mindset, Cesar B. Bautista, Mapping the future, Philippine Daily Inquirer, 10th May 2015]

It’s worth repeating that the [UPSS] econometricians examined the gross domestic product and other potential [hunger] determinants and found little correlation with them.

Let’s hold it right there.

Here’s a quote from an earlier posting: “Over the last fourteen years, the blog has raised several bodies of knowledge to challenge our worldview. And they are not from an academic but a practitioner. 

“We need to develop a hardy mindset.

“We can’t be both Juan Tamad and Bondying rolled into one. What is a hardy mindset? It embraces (1) the challenge one faces and (2) the commitment to overcome it while (3) recognizing that one has no control over others but themselves. In other words, the onus to change is on Juan de la Cruz.

“We must distinguish (a) logical yet linear and incremental thinking and (b) forward, lateral, and creative thinking.

“The blog has been critical of our economic managers, legislators, and think tanks. Like Laos, we delivered the global metric of a 6%-7% GDP growth rate for over a decade. Yet, both countries remained underdeveloped.

“And we know that we are standing on the shoulders of Juan de la Cruz – to the tune of over $50 billion. Our economy is driven by what they bring in via OFW remittances and call centers.

Said differently, BSP has “excess funds” because of said remittances. It does not come from the economy per se. Our trade balance is underwater because our meager export receipts can’t cover our imports.

How much will Maharlika add to GDP growth because it will fund infrastructure and social programs? A fraction of a percent? 

“Why are our economic managers, legislators, and think tanks not figuring out what else we must develop income stream-wise?”

Because of hubris, we have been reinventing the wheel because we are “economically savvy,” and our neighbors aren’t. See below; Vietnam’s export machinery dwarfs our over 400 export zones.

Should we learn how Nadella transformed Microsoft, “From know it all to learn it all”?

Here’s something from Davos: “Marcos gets pledges but investment analysts unimpressed,” BusinessWorld, 20th Jan 2023.

“Terry L. Ridon, a public investment analyst, said the commitment from Morgan Stanley to build a Manila office does not constitute a commitment to undertake foreign direct investment (FDI) in the Philippines. The investment bank’s primary business involves not FDIs but portfolio investments.

“The president does not need to go to Davos if only to convince DP World to expand its operations in the country, i.e., judge the president’s trip on the total cost of funding the delegation against existing investment pledges originating from the WEF itself.

“Mr. Marcos’ office should have been more forthright in presenting the trip as nothing more than a speaking tour to manage public expectations. The public can see news out of Davos that the trip has essentially been a speaking engagement for the president to promote the country to the world.

“Foreign investment commitments should have already been perfected by government negotiators before the Philippine leader’s foreign trips, adding that the trips should only serve as a venue for the formal signing of diplomatic or economic agreements.

“The Philippines faces growth risks from elevated inflation, rising borrowing costs, and a global recession. The World Bank expects the economy to slow to 5.4% this year from an estimated 7.2% last year.”

If our economic managers are listening, whose heads must now roll? We can fool Juan de la Cruz, but the global community isn’t naĆÆve!

What about political patronage and oligarchy blocking efforts to make us a competitive market for FDIs? It’s not the over 400 export zones under PEZA. They confirm our crab mentality and expand the opportunity for smugglers. 

But our economic managers, who must know better, better exercise horizontal leadership and demonstrate the pursuit of the common good.

The challenge to our economic managers, legislators, and think tanks is to move from “know it all” to “learn it all.”

To match the dynamism of our neighbors, we in the Philippine elite and chattering classes must “learn it all” too, from psychology to philosophy to physics, economics to theology. It’s called cross-discipline thinking, the key to unlocking forward, lateral, and creative thinking demanded by the 21st century.

Look at all the initiatives we proudly pursued to create jobs and address poverty and inclusion. Yet, none would correlate and directly generate substantial income streams. 

Logical yet linear and incremental thinking makes us proud that we grew GDP by 6%-7% over a decade while we remained underdeveloped – and the laughingstock of the region.

Recall how the blog would distinguish “analysis” from “analytics.” Here’s what “analysis” would look like: “The [UPSS] econometricians examined the gross domestic product and other potential determinants and found little correlation with them.

Recall how we celebrated green shoots and the manufacturing uptick in 2015. In other words, aren’t we doing what they call an “after-action review” in the military?

How many of these shortsighted analyses have we promoted through the media that were proven to be such shortsighted? We are in the “real world,” not the classroom.

The Maharlika Investment Fund is the latest fiasco. [See above; how much will Maharlika add to GDP growth?] Worse, this insanity has gone overboard if not “criminal.” Consider the hypothesis that OFW remittances would make up for the absence of industrialization. 

And Maharlika is the added insult to injury. In other words, hubris is beyond the pale.

We are still pushing fiscal and monetary interventions that brought about millions of hungry and poor Filipinos.

Messrs. Diokno and Balisacan would be out the door if they committed such blunders in the private sector.

Enter “analytics.” Think of the concept of sets and subsets. We cannot correlate “analysis” being a subset to its more substantial set, “analytics,” if we can’t do forward, lateral, and creative thinking.

See above; investment analysts weren’t impressed by the Maharlika Investment Fund.

In other words, our economic managers can’t delve beyond fiscal interventions because we have no experience outside classical economics. “Beg for Western money and technology” was the mantra of the Asian Tigers because they saw that leapfrogging industrialization would accelerate their journey from poverty to prosperity. Unsurprisingly, they became the most significant exporters, to the amazement of the West and the rest of the world.

Let’s drill that down. 

Vietnam is the latest example. But before we replay the Vietnam example, let’s pause and ponder.

Question: How do we leapfrog industrialization? We have Arangkada, AmBisyon, and the scores of industry road maps. But why can’t we move forward?

Recall the force field theory: Exploit the driving forces and right the restraining ones.

Consider: BOI reported adopting the Pareto principle to focus on “big ticket” items. That was after Mr. Ramon Ang shared his Bulacan initiative, which would generate $200 billion in export revenues beyond the Bulacan airport. And as the blog raised, we can include agribusiness under the Bulacan umbrella.

Those are multifaceted challenges. And recall the elements of cognitive development. Beyond binary thinking, there is multiplicity and relativism — the imperative of context.

The bottom line: How do we pull them all together? Beyond the restrictive economic provisions of the Constitution, we have countless sets and subsets to align and harmonize. And it goes back to overcoming binary thinking.

And it takes a village, and the Philippine elite and chattering classes could be the nucleus to lead this multifaceted challenge.

But then, can the economic managers, legislators, and think tanks update their respective portfolios and show the way?

We can return to the Vietnam example to make the exercise more tangible.

“2017 was a year of great significance for both the Vietnamese economy and Samsung Vietnam. Vietnam’s export turnover for the first time in history reached more than 214 billion USD, and Samsung Vietnam’s export turnover also achieved a breakthrough with more than 54 billion USD for the first time.

“Samsung Vietnam contributes more than 25% to the total export turnover of Vietnam. This miraculous figure is 150 times higher than Samsung Vietnam’s total export turnover in 2009 ($350 million) when SEV began production.

“As of June 2018, Samsung has reached the milestone of 1 billion high-tech innovative products manufactured in Vietnam. The 1 billion products include smartphones, tablets, smartwatches, and other essential mobile phone products.

“The Samsung Bac Ninh factory produced more than 625 million products, and Samsung Thai Nguyen made more than 431 million. Vietnam is currently the second largest smartphone export in the world after China, and Samsung plays a significant role in this achievement. 

“In terms of infrastructure, Samsung has built four manufacturing centers in Vietnam and a newly developed R&D center. These manufacturing centers contain housing, schools, medical centers, and gyms to serve their employees. Other entities under the Samsung group have also invested heavily in their manufacturing facilities in the country.

“Samsung has also invested in infrastructure such as roads, electricity, and water networks in the areas near their manufacturing centers. These infrastructures not only serve Samsung’s facilities but they have a positive impact on the host city and its citizens as well.

“The operation of large electronics corporations like Samsung entails a huge ecosystem to support its production and business activities.” [The effect Samsung has on the economy of Vietnam (viettonkinconsulting.com)]

Recall how often the blog raised the Pearl River Delta Economic Zone ecosystem (in Guangdong, China) as the best practice model to attract foreign money and technology. And all that Vietnam did was replicate the China experience and find a partner in Samsung.

Let’s hold it right there.

Why does the blog keep distinguishing “analysis” and “analytics”? See above; the 50-year ‘disease’ in Philippine agriculture. Yet, from rice tariffication, we are doing the rest of the agri products to address shortages. That is how “analysis” looks. On the other hand, the Vietnamese learned “analytics” from the Asian Tigers, which they translated to “ecosystem.” See above; the operations of Samsung entail a vast ecosystem. And not to forget that Vietnam is a top rice exporter like Thailand. The agri ecosystem of both countries is something we want to learn. It is beyond liberalizing the agriculture sector.

The story’s moral: The Vietnamese embraced “learn it all” and not “know it all.”

And they are doing it in the field of education too. “Grounded on Lewin’s three-stage change model (1951) and an appreciation of the benefits of leadership theories and organizational change, this mixed-method case study sought to present stages in change implementation in an academic division of a Vietnamese university.” [“Implementing Lewin’s Change Theory for Institutional Improvements: A Vietnamese Case Study,” Tuyet Thi Tran and Franco Gandolfi, Journal of Management Research, Vol. 20, No. 4, October - December 2020, pp. 01-12]

What about Philippine education?

As with the economy, Philippine education is down the cellar. Yet, why the hubris?

When are we moving from “know it all” to “learn it all”?

“I think people are looking to business to help solve problems like climate change, healthcare, income inequality, food shortages, and supply chain.

“Government is not set up to deal with those things. They can pass laws but can’t address them, which is why everyone’s looking to business. That’s the challenge for today’s leaders: if they don’t address today’s problems, they won’t be good leaders, I can tell you.” [George, op. cit.]

In other words, should our economic managers merely bend to our politicians even when our “Government isn’t up to deal with our decades-old challenges, including hunger and poverty? They can pass laws but can’t address them, which is why everyone’s looking to business.

It’s called horizontal leadership.

And we in the Philippine elite and chattering classes better step up to the plate – or we won’t be good leaders too.

But first, we must shift from “know it all” to “learn it all.”

Sadly, it’s a tall order given our caste system: We are parochial and insular. We value hierarchy and paternalism and rely on political patronage and oligarchy; ours is a culture of impunity.

Over the last fourteen years, the blog has raised several bodies of knowledge to challenge our worldview. And they are not from an academic but a practitioner. 

Gising bayan!