Sunday, December 11, 2022

nnovation is beyond R&D; Nation-building is beyond Economics

That will be a challenge, a restraining force, in our effort to move the Philippines forward.

Recall the force-field theory. To manage change, we must (a) exploit the driving forces; and (b) fix the restraining ones.

And the challenge comes from our caste system. It explains why we keep shrinking our playing field. And why the knee-jerk is all left to us – and why we can’t imagine the limitations of logical yet linear and incremental thinking.

And part of our caste system is the “ivory tower” syndrome that perpetuates “specialization” while missing out on the “creative process.”

Recall that Steve Jobs defined creativity as simply connecting the dots. We know it as “brainstorming,” the more contemporary model being “design thinking,” which captures the Silicon Valley culture of innovation and global competitiveness. And that presupposes learning how to forward thinking – and lateral and creative thinking.

And it has taken a life of its own, being the character of the 21st century.

But connecting the dots demands more, so we must also learn to translate the “ecosystem” we know as the photosynthesis phenomenon into a tangible model that we can “touch and feel.”

In other words, instead of rolling our eyes when we hear that we are a subset of this universe, dynamic and in constant motion and expansion, we must remember Darwin’s survival of the fittest. In other words, because of the inherent hierarchy of human needs, humankind had to migrate from Africa. And we had to learn that there is a better chance of survival if we graduate from being cave dwellers.

That is a roundabout way to explain that the hierarchy of human needs is the bedrock of innovation.

Let’s hold it right there.

Can we stop, pause, and internalize the above set of predicates in the pursuit of nation-building?

How do we then upend the Philippine caste system? Do we start with education? What about the home? What about the public and private sectors?

First, let’s tackle education. How do we upend the “ivory tower” syndrome? How do we get UP, for example, to move beyond “academic freedom” to mirroring the dynamism of this universe? That we are a subset of a dynamic ecosystem, we know as the photosynthesis phenomenon? In other words, it is not about K-12.

Recall how George Gorospe (SJ) defined “reality;” it is beyond any human experience or system. And recall too how the Philippine culture conflicts with this fundamental given. While the school can instruct the students accordingly, the home and the workplace undermine the effort because of our caste system.

Nation-building “is no longer just economics. We must open our eyes and focus on a bigger canvas, not just economic indicators. Still, most social, political, and other inequality indicators frustrate our efforts to build social cohesion and unite people around certain reforms.” [“PHL urged to focus economic policy on keeping middle class prosperous,” BusinessWorld, 24th Nov 2022]

Let’s drill that down – and start with our instincts, reflected in the Philippine caste system: We are parochial and insular. We value hierarchy and paternalism and rely on political patronage and oligarchy; ours is a culture of impunity.

Can we connect the dots from parochialism to a culture of impunity – given our instincts?

In other words, because we value hierarchy and paternalism, we equated economic development to creating jobs to address poverty and “inclusion,” a tacit and feeble effort to attain social equilibrium.

Here’s a quote from an earlier posting. Laos and the Philippines have been amongst the fastest in Asia, averaging more than 7% GDP growth per year for most of the last decade. Yet, both are cellar dwellers compared to the rest of the region.

The bottom line: the platform of Philippine economic development is a fallacy. It does not get us where we want to be.

How did we get here — beyond crafting a restrictive Constitution?

Recall that our education system follows the West, including Economics. We had to expound our understanding of deficit spending, for example, then the buzzword at Harvard. And so we employed the same tools they did, including monetary and fiscal interventions. I still remember my paper in Economics 101 [in the MBA program.]

On the other hand, our neighbors, who would become the Asian Tigers, saw through the missing piece: The West had already traversed the journey from agriculture to industry.

Unsurprisingly, Lee and Mahathir quickly shared this with Deng, “Beg for Western money and technology, to lift the Chinese people from poverty.” And Mahathir shared it with us too. Sadly, we’re too highfalutin. And it comes from the Philippines caste system. We higher up in the hierarchy enjoy the privileges of omnipotence.

In other words, our neighbors became first-world economies by leapfrogging industrialization and are today the most significant exporters. [Recall the header of this blog of over 12 years and why it hasn’t ceased challenging us: “Philippine Economy: Reinventing Ourselves.”]

These neighbors understood where their nations were in the hierarchy of human needs.

And the hierarchy is a continuum – of physiological to self-actualization. Said differently, from the need to survive to the need to be prosperous.

It is not only the Philippine elite that needs self-actualization or prosperity. Juan de la Cruz is beyond poverty, jobs, and inclusion. Prosperity is his right as it is ours.

And that means where we want to be is to be a first-world economy and nation. It is beyond creating jobs to address poverty and inclusion.

But that is why our economic managers – if they believe that nation-building is their portfolio – must learn “innovation.” And that the hierarchy of human needs is the bedrock of innovation.

And they must also learn “horizontal leadership,” which is an expression of “self-government” fundamental to freedom, democracy, and free enterprise. In other words, innovation is beyond R&D. And nation-building is beyond Economics.

Here’s a quote from an earlier posting. We must not only put the BOI in the crosshairs to match the Pearl River Delta Economic Zone – the center of the China economic miracle – or the Samsung-Vietnam partnership. We must also rack our brains to get Juan de la Cruz the basics of water, food, and electricity. Not because that is easy but because it is hard. Think of the Kennedy moonshot speech.

In other words, the China economic miracle mirrors an ecosystem, reflected by the photosynthesis phenomenon. 

But we don’t have to reinvent the wheel and instead task the BOI to restate the ecosystem that is the Pearl River Delta Economic Zone. 

That means thinking out of the box and tossing our PEZA model because it pales in comparison.

Said differently, can the BOI build on the Ang Bulacan initiative to mirror the success of the Pearl River Delta Economic Zone?

Innovation is beyond R&D; Nation-building is beyond Economics.

That will be a challenge, a restraining force, in our effort to move the Philippines forward.

Recall the force-field theory. To manage change, we must (a) exploit the driving forces; and (b) fix the restraining ones.

And the challenge comes from our caste system. It explains why we keep shrinking our playing field. And why the knee-jerk is all left to us – and why we can’t imagine the limitations of logical yet linear and incremental thinking.

The latest evidence? The Maharlika Wealth Fund. It is classic “Pinoy abilidad.” Yet, while it has tons of detractors, there are still supporters. Look, whom did we elect as President? 

But that is par for the course, given that we hue closer to autocracy than democracy. And why we applauded China, Russia, and whoever else because we can’t fathom the continuum of authoritarianism to freedom. And instead, we like to debate human constructs as in a system.

Democracy is “self-government.” The system we like to criticize is of our making.

But that is why we can’t upend the Philippine caste system.

Do we start with education? What about the home? What about the public and private sectors?

Nation-building “is no longer just economics. We must open our eyes and focus on a bigger canvas, not just economic indicators.” 

Gising bayan!

Wednesday, December 7, 2022

6-year industrialization plan

Consider this news item: “DTI to present 6-year industrialization plan. The DTI and Board of Investments (BOI) will hold the first-ever Industrial Digital Transformation Congress (IDTC) on Dec. 6. Trade Secretary Alfredo Pascual will present the agency’s six-year industrialization direction.

“For the past six years, guided by our ‘Inclusive Innovation Industrial Strategy (i3S),’ we have worked hard in establishing a solid foundation upon which our industries could stand firm and shoulder to shoulder with their global counterparts. As we move forward, we remain anchored on our longstanding vision that growth and development must be for all Filipinos. In this vein, the DTI adopts a new approach driven by science, technology, and innovation to capacitate and prepare our industries and us for what lies ahead.

“DTI is pursuing a renewed industrial policy that is science, technology, and innovation-(STI) driven. Through STI and essential digital technologies, industries can transform and face competition in domestic and export markets. Dynamic industry ecosystems are the foundation for generating quality jobs and investments, creating new products and services, and improving environmental sustainability.”

The above efforts are welcome given the following news: “PHL urged to focus economic policy on keeping middle class prosperous. Income inequality did not begin to decline until 2012. It is still high: the top 1% of earners together capture 17% of national income, with only 14% shared by the bottom 50%.

“It’s no longer just economics. We must open our eyes and focus on a bigger canvas, not just economic indicators. Still, most social, political, and other inequality indicators frustrate our efforts to build social cohesion and unite people around certain reforms.”

It’s worth repeating the following: We must open our eyes and focus on a “bigger” canvas, not just economic indicators. Laos and the Philippines have been amongst the fastest in Asia, averaging more than 7% GDP growth per year for most of the last decade. Yet, both are cellar dwellers compared to the rest of the region.

Without being privy to the full story of the 6-year industrialization plan, I have a question: Is the focus on digital transformation key across the priority industry clusters? The industry clusters are (1) industrial, manufacturing, and transport (IMT); (2) technology, media, and telecommunications (TMT); (3) health and life sciences (HLS); (4) and modern basic needs and resilient economy (MBNRE).

Note that the service sector drives the Philippine economy by 61% against 31% by the industry sector.

And so, the next question is, isn’t the shortcoming of the initial industrialization plan the failure to make a quantum leap in the industry sector?

I am a practitioner, not an academic, but I can confirm from decades of industry experience the real-world import of the force-field theory. To manage change, we must (a) put front and center the forces driving the change and, as necessary, (b) the forces restricting the change. 

In other words, before we embrace an STI-driven plan, shouldn’t we first figure out what has restrained our industrialization efforts? Said differently, we’re dealing with the “real world” – dynamic yet chaotic – and must overcome the “ivory tower” syndrome.

That is why the blog keeps raising our instincts, reflected in the Philippine caste system: We are parochial and insular. We value hierarchy and paternalism and rely on political patronage and oligarchy; ours is a culture of impunity.

And so, back to the question, how do we take a quantum leap in the industry sector? For example, to match the export revenues of our neighbors, we must drive industry – doggedly – to generate incremental exports of $200 billion.

And the next logical question will be, which of the priority industry clusters must we prioritize to get us to the $200 billion?

I have led digital transformation – in my previous and current lives – counting decades. For example, how many Philippine companies have installed SAP, and how many can leverage “analytics” to meet the 21st-century challenge of “innovation and global competitiveness”?

In other words, digital technology is a tool but not every enterprise is ready for it. Of course, telecommunication must digitize. And we have that with digital banking.

Back to the question: Which of the priority industry clusters must we prioritize to generate “incremental” exports of $200 billion? And the next question will be, what products and services must they have in the portfolio that will confirm the projected revenues?

And that is where we talk about innovation and global competitiveness. What is the product architecture (of these products and services) that will give it a leg up against the domestic and international competition? The product architecture amplifies the hierarchy of human needs – from “basic” to self-actualization.

Recall from a prior posting that I was impressed by Axelum, highlighted by the Bernie Villegas article (Hope for coconut farmers.) For example, of their $125 million revenues, 33% still comes from desiccated coconut. But coconut water accounts for 25%, with coconut milk at 15%, sweetened coconut at 14%, and coconut milk/cream at 3%. Also noteworthy is that 75% goes to the US, and only 8% remains in the Philippines, with the balance shared by Europe, Australia, and Asia.

They are a great example of getting Philippine agribusiness on the world map. They employ over 5,000 people and support coconut farmers and their communities.

They are a best practice model. 

If I were doing the one-day DTI event, I would highlight Axelum Resources – to translate the tech lingo into a successful real-world enterprise and for the rest to emulate, if not replicate.

The Axelum website illustrates the continuum of their product architecture, traversing the hierarchy of human needs from basic to self-actualization: “Axelum is a fully-integrated manufacturer and exporter of premium coconut products for leading domestic and international food and beverage companies, confectioneries, bakeries, private label supermarkets, grocery store chains, food service enterprises, and “nutritional” and personal care brands. The Company offers an extensive line of products, including desiccated coconut, coconut water, sweetened coconut, coconut powder, coconut milk/cream, coconut oil, and reduced-fat coconut.” 

They are a departure from the typical Filipino enterprise that caters to the “bottom of the pyramid,” meaning low-quality economy products. Note that they emphasized “exporter of premium” products.

That is how to meet the 21st-century challenge of innovation and global competitiveness. And the Company’s industry-leading net-margin performance (i.e., double digits) proves its world-class caliber — the outcome of its ability to drive revenues double digits in the first place because of the superior “ecosystem” they pulled together.

In other words, Philippine enterprises — big, small, micro, or mini — must shift paradigms. It must not be to create jobs to address poverty and “inclusion” but to be a first-world economy and nation by being the epitome of innovation and global competitiveness.

DTI is just one of our economic institutions. We have other “economic managers.”

Let’s quote again from a prior posting: Beyond the role of the Philippine President to aggressively attract Western money and technology, the economic managers will have to learn “horizontal leadership” if they want to succeed in selling the idea that nation-building – or, more specifically, economic development – is their portfolio.

Recall the blog’s discussion on innovation being beyond R&D. The brand manager is in the best position to pull the different pieces together, which is why they must learn “horizontal leadership.” Why? Because the hierarchy of human needs – from physiological to self-actualization, e.g., prosperity – is the bedrock of innovation. And brand managers must be committed to thoroughly internalizing these needs because innovation is not for innovation’s sake but to respond to a human “need.” That’s why Steve Jobs proved to be a better innovator than his peers.

That brings us to a continuum: the basics of water, food, and electricity at the physiological level to prosperity reflected in the characteristics of a first-world nation. And we don’t have to reinvent the wheel: Beg for foreign money and technology – so that we replicate the journey of Singapore as articulated by Lee.

We must not only put the BOI in the crosshairs to match the Pearl River Delta Economic Zone – the center of the China economic miracle – or the Samsung-Vietnam partnership. We must also rack our brains to get Juan de la Cruz the basics of water, food, and electricity. Not because that is easy but because it is hard. Think of the Kennedy moonshot speech.

That is what our economic managers must be able to articulate: They will have to learn “horizontal leadership” if they want to succeed in selling the idea that nation-building – or, more specifically, economic development – is their portfolio. Recall that horizontal leadership is an expression of “self-government,” which is fundamental to freedom, democracy, and free enterprise.

Let’s drill that down.

Suppose the hypothesis to generate “incremental” exports of $200 billion starts with the Ang Bulacan airport initiative, including an export economic zone with TMCC as the anchor. In that case, the BOI can build on said hypothesis.

And that is where the Pearl River Delta Economic Zone and the Samsung-Vietnam partnership will come in. In other words, we don’t have to reinvent the wheel. BOI has to restate the two models down to the granular level. It means we want to recreate a benchmark that we can “touch and feel.”

There are several ways to do that. The blog has given the example of Toyota and how it recreated a benchmark by dismantling premium German cars. And my Eastern European friends did something similar. They “unbundled” the best-selling competing brand that they were able to “touch and feel” how to be the best in class.

BOI must be able to “touch and feel” the best in class, i.e., the Pearl River Delta Economic Zone and the Samsung-Vietnam partnership.

They want to have a platform to exercise “horizontal leadership.”

Translation: They must then pull together the rest of the public and private sectors that will make up the Philippine version of the best-in-class model – to edify and dialogue with them.

That is where we want to be with the Bulacan Economic Zone or the Samsung-Vietnam partnership version. And that is how to visualize it, an “ecosystem” akin to the photosynthesis phenomenon.

In other words, the model will include the basics of water and electricity, among others, but better than the typical Philippine Economic Zone, given its magnitude and scale. For example, we may be able to pursue solar energy because of economies of scale.

We can even include the Bulacan version of Axelum (with its plant in Misamis Oriental), given that Calabarzon is a major coconut producer and is less than 200 km away. And coconut is the largest agri export of the Philippines. What other agribusiness enterprises can we incorporate into the Bulacan model? And beyond TMCC, what other electronic-based companies and technologies can we lure to the Philippines?

But that means whatever past and present investment incentive programs we have created will no longer suffice. We must think out of the box.

We need an industrialization plan badly.

But we better do our homework, so we don’t turn them into dust collectors like AmBisyon, Arangkada, and the scores of industry road maps.

Are our economic managers listening? What about our legislators? And “think tanks”?

“It’s no longer just economics. We must open our eyes and focus on a bigger canvas, not just economic indicators. Still, most social, political, and other inequality indicators frustrate our efforts to build social cohesion and unite people around certain reforms.”

Gising bayan!

Saturday, December 3, 2022

The Filipino crab mentality is incompatible with “self-government.”

If we can’t recognize where we are, we can’t figure out where we want to be, much less how to get there.

And the crab mentality comes from our instincts, expressed in the Philippine caste system.

In other words, “self-government” presupposes the “common good.”

Where are we with AmBisyon? With Arangkada? Whatever happened to the scores of industry road maps that we proudly created?

Why can’t we embrace and run with the common good?

Consider: We are prouder of the Mandanas law because it builds on our value of LGUs and the party-list system.

Unsurprisingly, our economic managers have the following to say: Our LGUs must take on more of the initiatives formerly done by the central government. 

I want to cry. I would hear something like this from young brand managers – still “wet behind the ears” – but not from more senior managers – who can see the “bigger” canvas.

Then think of the comprehensive agrarian reform program, the 4Ps, the OFW phenomenon, and call centers.

We are Christian-like and must address poverty via job creation and “inclusion.”

We are prouder still that we satisfy the global yardstick of 6%-7% GDP growth.

Our economic managers, legislators, and “think tanks” reinforce the Philippine caste system. 

Why? Because it values the “ivory tower” too. And the model is Western, which we admire. But as the blog points out, the model assumes that these Western economies have already traversed the journey from agriculture to industry. And it explains why the US, for example, overtook the UK following WWII.

And that was not lost on Asian leaders like Lee and Mahathir: Beg for Western money and technology.

News item: “PHL urged to focus economic policy on keeping middle class prosperous. Income inequality did not begin to decline until 2012. It is still high: the top 1% of earners together capture 17% of national income, with only 14% shared by the bottom 50%.

“It’s no longer just economics. We must open our eyes and focus on a bigger canvas, not just economic indicators. Still, most social, political, and other inequality indicators frustrate our efforts to build social cohesion and unite people around certain reforms.”

And whom do we keep company? “The government of Laos, one of the few remaining one-party communist states, began decentralizing control and encouraging private enterprise in 1986. Economic growth averaged more than 6% per year from 1988-2008. Laos’ development has more recently been amongst the fastest in Asia, averaging more than 7% per year for most of the last decade.

“Nevertheless, Laos remains a country with an underdeveloped infrastructure, particularly in rural areas. It has a basic but improving road system and limited external and internal land-line telecommunications. Electricity is available to 83% of the population. Agriculture, dominated by rice cultivation in lowland areas, accounts for about 20% of the GDP and 73% of total employment. Recently, the country has faced a persistent current account deficit, including falling foreign currency reserves and growing public debt.”

How do we shift paradigms? First, we must recognize that our caste system, including our value of the “ivory tower,” will explain why we have sunk deeper into the abyss.

The 21st-century lingo – of critical thinking, creativity, collaboration, and communication – is foreign to us.

But we must not be surprised, given we pigeon-holed Juan de la Cruz in his rank.

We take it as a given that the only way to drive the economy is to keep to the 6%-7% metric. That is why we celebrated the third-quarter GDP growth.

If we can shift paradigms, we will find a different world. Sadly, we’re centuries behind.

Consider: “While the WB paper is an edifying read, it has a limited past perspective, thereby ignoring the population factor, which has made a crucial difference in the current state of the country vis-à-vis its ASEAN neighbors that used to trail it. The Philippines initiated a population management-cum-family planning (PM-FP) program in 1970, along with other ASEAN countries. However, while the others sustained their programs over time without letup, the Philippines was constrained to jettison its program in the late ‘70s on orders of President Marcos Sr., who acceded for political expediency to the demands of the Catholic Church hierarchy.” [“Poverty and inequality in the Philippines,” Ernesto M. Pernia, The Philippine Daily Inquirer, 2nd Dec 2022]

What say you? If the WB paper has a limited perspective, doesn’t the above article fall into the same trap?

The Philippine economy relies on the OFW phenomenon and call centers. Period. Full stop.

Translation: Our neighbors left us behind because they begged for Western money and technology and are today the world’s most significant exporters.

Here’s a quote from a prior posting: Begin with the end in mind – to clear the cobwebs in our heads. How do we shift paradigms? Think of the seven habits of highly effective people by Stephen Covey. For example, Be Proactive.

And the rest goes: Put first things first; Think win-win; Seek first to understand, then to be understood; Synergize; Sharpen the saw – or continuous improvement.

We must open our eyes and focus on a “bigger” canvas, not just economic indicators.

For example, the giant canvas exceeds the 6%-7% GDP growth metric. We must be a first-world economy and nation. Recall what Lee Kuan Yew said. From the third to the first world: The Singapore story.

Can we turn things on their heads? How do we open our eyes and focus on a giant canvas?

Those familiar with the blog may know that it often speaks to the modern math concept of sets and subsets.

That is how to recognize best that we are a subset of a dynamic universe in constant motion and expansion. It is not rocket science; we learned it from the photosynthesis phenomenon in grade school.

Beyond dynamism, the universe teaches us about the “common good” – or “self-government.”

Sadly, the Filipino crab mentality is incompatible with self-government.

How do we turn things on their heads?

Recall the Ang Bulacan airport project that includes an economic zone targeted to generate $200 billion in exports — to match our neighbors.

That gives us a better perspective of where we want to be instead of the 6%-7% GDP growth metric.

Moreover, it will facilitate prioritizing initiatives with the extra plus of creating an “ecosystem” – that will connect the dots and not fall flat on our faces.

Keep the $200 billion in exports in mind and then read the following: “If there are large corporate groups that are now considering getting into palm oil production, especially in Mindanao, there is even more reason for those contemplating large-scale corporate farming to invest in coconuts to take advantage of the growing demand worldwide for the numerous food products manufactured from this crop such as coconut water, coconut milk, coconut sugar, shredded organic coconut, virgin coconut oil (VCO), coco jam, and many others, not to mention the non-food derivatives like coconut charcoal, coir, and husks for biothermal uses.

“There are a few models of small coconut farmers organized by a large corporate enterprise such as Cardinal Agri Products in Brookes Point, Palawan, not far from Lionheart Farms, and Axelum Resources Corp. in Medina, Misamis Oriental. The ultimate result is that they can consolidate the products of thousands of small farmers and help them improve productivity at the farm level and transform their coconuts into food items that fetch more value than copra or coconut oil.” [“Hope for coconut farmers: What the President can do,” Bernardo M. Villegas, Human Side of Economics, BusinessWorld, 29th Nov 2022]

That is a step in the right direction. But how much are we going to generate from the initiative? 

For example, I googled Axelum and was impressed by the quality of the company and its business. For 2022, its revenues could be $125 million. That is not bad.

But let’s return to the Ang initiative that will generate $200 billion.

Recall the challenge the blog posed: We must not only put the BOI in the crosshairs to match the Pearl River Delta Economic Zone or the Samsung Vietnam partnership. We must also rack our brains to get Juan de la Cruz the basics of water, food, and electricity. Not because that is easy but because it is hard. Think of the Kennedy moonshot speech.

In other words, we must shift paradigms away from erecting over 400 export processing zones — that could only do $80 billion — and figure out how to generate rapidly $200 billion in exports. Samsung Vietnam does $50 billion by itself.

“With the liberalization of Foreign Direct Investments, there should be a concerted effort to replicate the success story of Lionheart Farms.

“He [BBM] can focus much of his effort to attract foreign investors to large-scale investments in agribusiness, replicating our success stories with the likes of Del Monte and Dole in the past. I find it providential that the President chose to be Secretary of Agriculture.

“Increasing agricultural productivity requires very close coordination among several government departments like the Department of Agriculture (DA), the Department of Agrarian Reform (DAR), the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR), and the Department of the Interior and Local Government (DILG). More often than not, these departments act as islands and have very little coordination with their respective policies and programs.” [Villegas, op. cit.]

Coconut is not the wrong industry to pursue. Still, given our need to rapidly overcome Juan de la Cruz’s abject poverty and learning poverty, we must prioritize export industries consistent with the Ang initiative, i.e., we want incremental exports of $200 billion.

If we find that overwhelming, recall that neither China nor Vietnam had the infrastructure to attract billions in export partners. We can add India to the mix. I represented my old Fortune 500 company when we invested in these countries. The infrastructure was abysmal, but they could fast-track the effort because they had a clear view of the “bigger canvas.”

In other words, we cannot keep raising self-imposed barriers to move the Philippines from third to the first world.

Let’s get back to the economic managers.

Beyond the role of the Philippine President to aggressively attract Western money and technology, the economic managers will have to learn “horizontal leadership” if they want to succeed in selling the idea that nation-building – or, more specifically, economic development – is their portfolio.

Recall the blog’s discussion on innovation being beyond R&D. The brand manager is in the best position to pull the different pieces together, which is why they must learn “horizontal leadership.” Why? Because the hierarchy of human needs – from physiological to self-actualization, e.g., prosperity – is the bedrock of innovation. And brand managers must be committed to thoroughly internalizing these needs because innovation is not for innovation’s sake but to respond to a human “need.” That’s why Steve Jobs proved to be a better innovator than his peers.

Recall the blog’s discussion on the character of the 21st century, i.e., innovation and global competitiveness.

In other words, we better be the epitome of innovation and global competitiveness so that the Philippines does not keep company with Laos. And our economic managers must commit to internalizing the hierarchy of Juan de la Cruz’s needs – from physiological to self-actualization, e.g., prosperity, as exemplified by a first-world economy.

That brings us to a continuum: the basics of water, food, and electricity at the physiological level to prosperity reflected in the characteristics of a first-world nation. And we don’t have to reinvent the wheel: Beg for foreign money and technology – so that we replicate the journey of Singapore as articulated by Lee.

We must not only put the BOI in the crosshairs to match the Pearl River Delta Economic Zone – the center of the China economic miracle – or the Samsung Vietnam partnership. We must also rack our brains to get Juan de la Cruz the basics of water, food, and electricity. Not because that is easy but because it is hard. Think of the Kennedy moonshot speech.

That is what our economic managers must be able to articulate: They will have to learn “horizontal leadership” if they want to succeed in selling the idea that nation-building – or, more specifically, economic development – is their portfolio. Recall that horizontal leadership is an expression of “self-government,” which is fundamental to freedom, democracy, and free enterprise.

Then recall the characteristics of a hardy mindset. Commitment: To be involved with others and to experience a sense of purpose and meaning; how ordinary people can do extraordinary things.

Challenge: To appreciate that change rather than stability is the norm, new or difficult situations are learning opportunities, and the importance of “thinking outside the box.”

Control. Focus on situations where we influence, not where we have little if any, control; you have control only over yourself; you must be the one to change. Develop a problem-solving attitude; why can you not succeed in your efforts?

The bottom line: The Filipino crab mentality is incompatible with “self-government.”

If we can’t recognize where we are, we can’t figure out where we want to be, much less how to get there.

And the crab mentality comes from our instincts, expressed in the Philippine caste system.

Yet, no one wants to talk about it: We are parochial and insular. We value hierarchy and paternalism and rely on political patronage and oligarchy; ours is a culture of impunity.

Gising bayan!

Tuesday, November 29, 2022

In the company of Lao PDR

“The Philippines’s CRI (Commitment to Reduce Inequality) performance was dismal, as we ranked 102nd out of 161 globally and 19th out of 25 in East and the Pacific. Furthermore, we were 106th in public services spending, 104th in taxation, and 92nd in labor rights and welfare. These rankings put us second from the bottom, ahead only of Lao PDR, among the nine ASEAN member countries included.

“One area that needs more attention is enacting reforms that will encourage investments and structural change in our economy so that we create high-paying jobs and better entrepreneurial opportunities are available across the country.” [“Jobs generation: A tool for fighting inequality,” Sonny M. Angara, Better Days, BusinessMirror, 28th Oct 2022]

“The government of Laos, one of the few remaining one-party communist states, began decentralizing control and encouraging private enterprise in 1986. Economic growth averaged more than 6% per year from 1988-2008. Laos’ development has more recently been amongst the fastest in Asia, averaging more than 7% per year for most of the last decade.

“Nevertheless, Laos remains a country with an underdeveloped infrastructure, particularly in rural areas. It has a basic but improving road system and limited external and internal land-line telecommunications. Electricity is available to 83% of the population. Agriculture, dominated by rice cultivation in lowland areas, accounts for about 20% of the GDP and 73% of total employment. Recently, the country has faced a persistent current account deficit, including falling foreign currency reserves and growing public debt.

“Laos’ economy is heavily dependent on capital-intensive natural resource exports. The economy has benefited from high-profile foreign direct investment in hydropower dams along the Mekong River, copper and gold mining, logging, and construction. However, some projects in these industries have drawn criticism for their environmental impacts.

“Laos gained Normal Trade Relations status with the US in 2004 and applied for Generalized System of Preferences trade benefits in 2013 after being admitted to the World Trade Organization earlier in the year. Laos held the chairmanship of ASEAN in 2016. Laos is in the process of implementing a value-added tax system. The government appears committed to raising the country’s profile among foreign investors and has developed special economic zones replete with generous tax incentives. Still, a limited labor pool, a small domestic market, and corruption impede investment. Laos also has ongoing problems with the business environment, including onerous registration requirements, a gap between legislation and implementation, and unclear or conflicting regulations.” [Laos - The World Factbook (cia.gov)]

We keep that company, not Vietnam, China, or the earlier Asian Tigers. And it brings my mother to mind: Tell me who your friends are, and I will tell you who you are.

Her other constant reminder is: Honesty is the best policy. She attended the Philippine Normal School but did not have the chance to practice because of WWII. Still, she wanted me to learn leadership, so she had me join the Boys Scouts in high school. She failed to develop my study habits, and I was indolent.

I grew up with the rest of the neighborhood kids, playing in the streets after school. Fortunately, I demonstrated a knack for leadership by teaching the kids how to play softball, and we became the regular entertainment during school breaks.

I am no longer surprised that I kept the company of “winners, not losers.” Over the four years of high school, whatever groups of boys I led were the models – winning competitions as a matter of habit. Yet, it is not about winning per se. It is how we play the game, i.e., honesty is the best policy.

My Eastern European friends did not disappoint. If you want me around, you must commit to transparency, no ifs, and buts. In a region that woke up to Soviet-style tyranny, they stand out. We kept a new factory mothballed for a year instead of acquiescing to the demand for grease money – to be hooked to the power source. When we had our first trailer truck of products into Ukraine, we asked the driver to turn around instead of paying his way through.

Unsurprisingly, the country is proud of my friends and recognizes them as model exporters, generating 70% of revenues from exports. 

Conversely, why is the Philippines in the company of Lao PDR?

News item: “World Bank: Philippines has one of the widest wealth gaps in East Asia.”

Here’s another one: “PHL urged to focus economic policy on keeping middle class prosperous. Income inequality did not begin to decline until 2012. It is still high: the top 1% of earners together capture 17% of national income, with only 14% shared by the bottom 50%.

“It’s no longer just economics. We must open our eyes and focus on a bigger canvas, not just economic indicators. Still, most social, political, and other inequality indicators frustrate our efforts to build social cohesion and unite people around certain reforms.”

We must open our eyes and focus on a “bigger” canvas.

Consider: “I am happy to note that the Philippines has just survived the worst pandemic and economic crisis of the last 100 years.

“COVID-19 infected four million Filipinos. About 64,000 died. Another 60,000 died, but their cause of death didn’t attribute to COVID—an act of dishonesty during a time of grave peril.

“In the third quarter of 2022, the economy continued its frenetic growth after coming from a crippling 16.9 percent decline in the second quarter of 2020—the height of the pandemic.

“Since then, the economy pulled itself up, registering a remarkable 12.1 percent jump (Q2 2021) before steadying at a robust pace of 7.0 in Q3 2021, 7.8 in Q4 2021, 8.2 in Q1 2022, 7.5 in Q2 2022, and 7.6 in the third quarter this year.

“The 7.6 percent third quarter GDP growth beat everyone’s expectations.

“Against that happy backdrop, let me cite among the best CEOs who did spectacularly in the last two years and nine months.” [“The best,” Tony Lopez, Virtual Reality, manilastandard.net, 16th Nov 2022]

We must open our eyes and focus on a “bigger” canvas.

Why can’t we? 

(1) Because of the Philippine caste system, we cater to the top 1% that, in turn, shower us with paternalism.

(2) Moreover, we grew up emulating the economic model of the West despite decades of contrarian ways demonstrated by our neighbors. In other words, the West did not have to focus on a giant canvas because they had already traversed the journey from agriculture to industry. But we are too “ivory tower” to recognize the pitfall.

On the other hand, our neighbors had a straightforward mantra: Begging for Western money and technology. In other words, they knew they had to leapfrog the development journey and be first-world economies sooner than later. 

In the meantime, given our logical yet linear and incremental thinking, we love analysis; but have not developed the big-picture view to learn analytics. Said differently, it is beyond us to reimagine the Philippines as a first-world economy.

Even more fundamentally, while we like to do our homework and sweat it out doing project studies and plans, we can’t “execute.”

“Our government finds it difficult to execute good plans and programs. Many agencies end the year with unutilized budgets. It is clear the taxpayers are not getting their money’s worth,” wrote Boo Chanco.

The blog is surprised the least. Recall that several times it asked, how many dissertations ever “see the light of day”? Or what happened to the scores of industry road maps we proudly developed? 

Or where are we with AmBisyon and Arangkada? 

Recall, too, that when I assisted a Ph.D. candidate with her dissertation, I was appalled at the number of dissertations I scanned that won’t ever get it to first base in the real world.

And so we had to revise the professor-approved outline, and after I said I would only assist you if you committed to pursuing a real-world challenge. Today, the once Ph.D. candidate is the global marketing director of a famous brand that can traverse the value chain of the product category instead of being stuck as a niche brand. How? She had to embrace the hierarchy of human needs, being the bedrock of innovation.

Conversely, given our mantra of 6%-7% GDP growth, please consider how much hubris we exude. Yet, we can’t provide Juan de la Cruz with the basics of water, food, and electricity. Then we turn around and claim we can’t industrialize because Philippine electricity is too expensive.

How badly do we need a hole in the head? 

Translation: If our economic managers are listening, as our legislators and “think tanks,” there is not one iota of justification – nada – for a nation of over 115 million not to provide the basics of water, food, and electricity.

We must not only put the BOI in the crosshairs to match the Pearl River Delta Economic Zone or the Samsung Vietnam partnership but also rack our brains to get Juan de la Cruz the basics of water, food, and electricity.

Not because that is easy but because it is hard. Think of the Kennedy moonshot speech.

We are too “ivory tower” to think out of the box — nor execute.

Thinking outside the box demands different skill sets, which we can’t acquire given our instincts, expressed in the Philippine caste system. That is why the blog has repeatedly raised the challenge of benchmarking against best practice models.

But the “ivory tower” won’t let us look outward, too. We’re stuck into the Western model of poverty and jobs – and “inclusion.”

Yet, decades of failed interventions must teach us a lesson. From CARL – the comprehensive agrarian reform law – to the 4Ps, to the OFW phenomenon, to call centers, among others, we failed to visualize the “bigger” canvas.

The bottom line: We are lost and can only see the trees but not the forest.

It is motherhood to say we must “encourage investments and structural change in our economy.

Instead, we must get ahead of the curve by visualizing economies of scale. Economies of scale must trump the Filipino crab mentality. And that means undoing the value hierarchy and paternalism, which perpetuates political patronage and oligarchy – and the perfect storm in our midst. 

Begin with the end in mind – to clear the cobwebs in our heads. Think of the seven habits of highly effective people by Stephen Covey. For example, Be Proactive.

And the rest goes: Put first things first; Think win-win; Seek first to understand, then to be understood; Synergize; Sharpen the saw – or continuous improvement.

Moreover, we are yet to internalize 21st-century skills: Critical Thinking; Creativity; Collaboration; Communication.

The problem with “critical thinking” is that it is too abstract. But there is a way to digest it, and it comes from the elements of cognitive development: dualism or binary thinking, multiplicity, and relativism.

In other words, to internalize critical thinking, we must recognize that the real world is beyond “binary thinking.”

The bottom line: Our best is not good enough. We are proud to be among the fastest growing economies doing 7% GDP growth, yet we are cellar dwellers. We are in the company of Laos.

At the rate we are going, the challenge Juan de la Cruz faces is way beyond our capacity.

We can’t settle for the status quo. Very soon, we shall find ourselves too deep into the abyss that the only thing left is for us to keep sinking.

We are in the company of Laos. How much deeper do we want to sink?

Gising bayan!